golaharsh on November 06, 2011
flawless singing!!!! cannot be any better!!! full respect.

P B Mathur on November 10, 2011
Very slow,like singing in front of family members.Just to impress them.

Abbu Jaani on November 13, 2011
Wat a Mess..Screwed up da whole beauty of the gr8 ghazal.

twinklerohit9 on November 14, 2011
be teri ma bhosada garbage

khanzamania on November 15, 2011
one of my fav songs sung by coke studio india.. hmm!

Rahul Cares on November 22, 2011
silky song :) heart gets nourished :)

Ddave on November 23, 2011
FLAWLESSS and simply BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!

fazrao on December 01, 2011
this is a roondi version. very well sung but cant listen to it again!

zebraorchid99 on December 15, 2011
Uhhh..no. Not as good as the original, not even as good as the version by
Shankar Tucker. She's trying but she's off. Don't waste your time.

Surendra Kumar on December 19, 2011
wah...wah...nice...different.

mksaeed1 on December 20, 2011
Nooooooooooo!!!!!! total fLOooop!!!

mksaeed1 on December 20, 2011
please don't mess with the legends!!!

said6993 on December 21, 2011
ye kesa coke studio hai jis main music he nahi hai?

monisrb on January 14, 2012
fazulllllllllllllllll aik dam 3rd class starting

Mxshanii on January 18, 2012
indian hr cheez hi copy kr lety hein :D

SameerGinwala on February 04, 2012
Thumbs 'Up' for Ramya

mixedupbigtime on February 06, 2012
now this makes me wanna leave this song and go watch the original Farida
Khanam's song..

PREDATOR925 on February 08, 2012
in indian music lots glitz and glammer but no creativty, no art,no artistic
freshness.. lot of new expensive instruments, lot of noise, lot of
glammer..poor music direction no real music

sephorahgore on February 08, 2012
O MY GOD! what an absolute disaster!

IamDon9999 on February 13, 2012
Damn try practicing Farida Khanum first !!!

aneela ali on February 17, 2012
hahhaha...bad very bad

aneela ali on February 17, 2012
coke cola wasting their investment in indian studio.lol

Jyotismita Das on February 21, 2012
I loooooove this song! She has sung it with soooo much soul. Beautiful.

MrPrateekchakraverty on March 01, 2012
@walkingdead93 well said!! there is lot more to do!

gauravkotak95 on March 01, 2012
See the irony... Wearing western clothes singing classical ghazals

BABADAANG11 on March 06, 2012
@tamalde well dear u r so innocent to under stand class of muzik, what do
think ghazal and sufi is a type of music,these r themes like others as folk
jazz even quwali,the base of all of these is classical which stands over
raag, ragnies, aalap. sergam, when u have command over these then u can
sing every thing like ustad n.fata ali khan, he makes many exp. like
fusion. who is rahat fata ali , shafqet amit ali khan khan. sanam marvi ,u
think he dont have any command over classical.lol

BABADAANG11 on March 06, 2012
@tamalde classical is about rraag ,raagni, allap. sergam,inven,by imeer
khuro r.a also many in Instruments.when u sing these classic with word or
poetry is called semi-classical .classical is roots of tree, semi-classical
is their branches nd other things like jazz, rox r leave . these gharas
singing from akbar mughal king darbar till today and u think they don't
know about classic??..lol ha ha ha,in 1947 all these came in pak. in pak,
it is said to their kids that they cry in sure,rag

Tamal De on March 09, 2012
@BABADAANG11 dude please read what i have written in my comment. I clearly
differentiatd between semi classical and classical music. I always agre
thatyou need clssica bas t go aheadon semi classical space but then that
doesnt remain your forte. I dont want to beat my own drums but I have
spent 14 years Learning classical music... I know whats the difference
between semi classical and pure classical.While I agree that semi
classical renditions are no childs play;

Tamal De on March 09, 2012
it does move the singer from the classical track at some stage... they can
never come back in that track. Ustad Nusrat faeh ali khan himself said
this in one of the concerts... All the siners you have mentioned are
great singers but areno more pure classical singers ad can/would never gt
back to the pure classical field. because the voice parameters change
mate (I know this because i have experienced this myself) ..

Tamal De on March 09, 2012
most Indian classcal singers singers have strictly followed the pure
regime. please havealook at th sangit research academy website and
singers... you would know what i am saying.. pleasedon misread me I am
in no way demeaning singers in your country but trust me my friend it has
become a business for most of tem. look at SRA website and show m one
such thing at your end. I would buy your words

Faizan Khurshid on March 10, 2012
For God Sake Indian Plz be Original stop Copy programmes

zebraorchid99 on March 15, 2012
Lol. I love the original song, it's one of my all-time favorite songs! This
version is a crime! Terrible. ugh.

Jasmin Kohli on March 16, 2012
absolutely disgusting!! HATE THIS..:(

sandies1204 on March 16, 2012
there must be something seriously wrong with people who can find this
rendition disgusting. it is a beautiful ghazal that has been sung very
well. full justice has been done to the original. well done!!

sandies1204 on March 18, 2012
i agree - one has to appreciate their guts and ... it really was performed
well. there would be nothing commendable about an exact copy.

Gogi Singh on March 22, 2012
Good voice, in fact great voice, bad try in fact horrible try especially
trying to go all sufi with added shairis. Crap!!

Vinay Gupta on March 29, 2012
Absolutely superb.

jack on April 11, 2012
great work !!!!

cum2love on April 20, 2012
go Listen To Theshrutibox and Composed by Shankar Tucker... sure you will
love it

Vidyut on May 01, 2012
sure buddy 1-0, you are too good.

Vidyut on May 02, 2012
Okay now I understand your point better. I'm sure your pristine passion for
good music transcends geographic boundaries, and may have taken you to
another url "The Dewarist". If not, then amongst the several nice ones on
it, here's one to relish: The Dewarists S01E03 - 'Maaya'

Kaku Boston on May 02, 2012
The Recreation is Copied though of OFRA Haza Kashmir Song
/watch?v=Fu5Cgb6Yy4Y&feature=related

Amaresh Jha on May 12, 2012
nice renedition..grea work.

admagman on May 14, 2012
# 1, it is so WRONG that Rehman is ONLY into films # 2, Bollywood is the
2nd biggest film fraternity in the world, and amongst all who make films
with songs, Bollywood is the biggest. The film music ranges from folk to
ballad to qawali to hip hop to rnb to jazz to classical etc etc. So, film
has nothing to do with this # 3, Coke Studio need to appoint a good
arranger first. Someone who is acquainted with the regional music of the 28
states and the 7 Union Territories.

admagman on May 14, 2012
# 4, they have to involve regional stars. regional music does not always
mean the suburbs and villages.. the urban musicians need to be involved.

admagman on May 14, 2012
Another thing one must accept is, most Mumbai musicians are so suffering
from Identity Crisis. That could be one of the reasons why they are not
involving the Regional Stars. They love to live in the bubble that Mumbai
is the place for smart music, and hence they do not wanna be proved wrong.

admagman on May 14, 2012
You can't compare Leslie Lewis with Rohail Hyatt.. There is A R Rehman,
Vishal Shekhar, Salim Sulaiman, Shankar Ehsaan Loy, Iliaya Raja, M M Kreem,
Hariss Jayaraj and many many more.. Stop comparing your art films with Star
Plus. It does not make sense. By the way, there is nothing called art film.
It is the term that exist only in underdeveloped nations or states. My
state in India is also behind, and they love using this term.

admagman on May 14, 2012
When did I say there are no composers of the calibre I am suggesting???
There are many in Mumbai.. Just that Coke Studio cannot afford them.. Also
there are many in Chennai, Kolkata, Guwahati, Delhi and Bangalore.. But
Coke Studio operations are restricted to Mumbai.. its a mindblock.. can't
help..

admagman on May 14, 2012
Heard all of these yesterday.. Bohemia outstanding.. got bowled.. What a
fantastic arrangement.. What fantastic presence.. Also like the Kamli track

twiceborne on May 15, 2012
and vica verca ... thats what families do ..