Jagjit Singh Ishar on June 25, 2010
ur extoling efforts r magnificent. tho lip movements do not coincide & that
is not possible but hv tried 2 give the best. two songs i wll suggest 4 u 2
b recreated "ghata ghanghor ghor mor machave shor mere sajan aaja" &
"panchhi bawra chaand se preet lagaye" i think the old movies r tansen &
bhagat sur dass. thanx.

tmjatala on June 26, 2010
1942 birth anniversary year of two "masterpieces." Ae chand chup na jana by
Kanan Devi and myself ( son of a school master ) . What a coincidence!, Aek
achi kawish , I guess the clips taken from , Singhar and Tarana . I really
appreciate your Funkari . Thanks for sharing, boht wadiya (nice)

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on June 26, 2010
Excellent way of reviving old gems. Thanks.

kalakar67 on June 27, 2010
GREAT JOB.!! KEEP IT UP...!!

jasbongy on June 27, 2010
So beautiful song and myvision22 ji you have made it more beautiful with
your artistic talent. Madhubala as graceful and beautiful is right choice
by you to give full justice to this awesome song. Music and lyrics are
great. Thumbs Up. Thanks for sharing. With respect. Sarla.

chandrashekharjain on June 30, 2010
WONDERFUL Real tribute to leged Kanan Devi ji song in a new look with
another legend Madhubala 'the beauty of indian screen' at the age of sweet
sixteen ( film Shringar).Such re- created videos re-surface the vintage
gems lest the present high-tech generation should forget them One should
keep in mind that matching of lips to the words ,dance movements & face
expression to the music especially by an amateur artist is not easy, still
Mr Mukhtar does it so successfully. CONGRATULATIONS SIR !!!

Eswar Nakka on July 04, 2010
Excellent re-mix. I one way you achieved 2 things, the best audi and the
best video of 2 different celebrities in one. The second one is, you won
our hearts. Blessings to you. Uma Maheswar Nakka

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on July 04, 2010
@mahesh1946 Thank you Maheswar ji

mazhar khan on July 09, 2010
wine of early forties in the bottle of 50s.lajawab

Asiftabrez on July 09, 2010
Super Hit posting dear.

Dilip Kapasi on July 23, 2010
Hummm.Madhubala and Dilipkumar's selection into this is perhaps
fine..but words coordination is NOT there..which must be there..Plus it
appears quite a bit flashy if you know what I mean... In Kananbala's own
voice, and in movie Jawab only...I love this song to my heart and no one
can take that away..so what can I say? Please if you do something keep a
straight focus, which you have. I respect that..

Shiv Shanker on August 05, 2010
Due to some technical problem this is not coming... I wll see it later for
sure... thanks

Vidur Sury on August 22, 2010
Great compilation. The heavenly voice of Melody Queen Madam Kanan Devi, who
is herself a breathtaking beauty, to the great performances of handsome
Dilip Kumar Sahab and Madhubala Ji. It was a true delight

V. Siddhartha on August 31, 2010
The female side of pre-Lata Indian music realm belonged to KD. I like your
remix here and in Lataji's tribute version very much, done with great
closeness to the train of lyrics as always. . Thank you, myvision22,

bazlur on February 24, 2011
here madhubala better looking than Mugle Azom. I'm from jessore and am
proud for Kamal Dasgupta. He was a rare talent in Bengali culture and music.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on February 25, 2011
@bazlur Dear friend, you should be proud of Kamal Dasgupta. He was a great
composer. Thanks

Moid Hasan on September 13, 2011
No-2 Kanan Devi started her film career with Kananbala as child star , in
silent film 1926,Joydev, an untrained singer,1935 Basabdatta and
Girls'School ,1937 Mukti (Barua) 1939 Street Singer 1939 jogijog and
Hospital, P.S.Barua was unable to obtain her for the role of Paro in Devdas
1935, but played the lead in his next film mikti 1935, her last film was
1959 Srikanta-o-Anandididi.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on September 13, 2011
@moidulhassan1 Dear Moidul Hassan sahib, Thanks for the vital information
of the bygone era. Best regards Mukhtar

Moid Hasan on September 14, 2011
What a fine and flawless mixing work by Mhkhtar bhai ,I really appreciate
and assay your efforts as professional one ,thanks Clip needs no comments
being superb.

Shiv Shanker on June 16, 2012
your efforts of reviving this old melody with recreating of a new video for
the song has been fruitful.. I could not view it when you uploaded it due
to some technical problem.. today I enjoyed it fully... very enjoyable ..
song as well as video.. congratulations Mukhtar Shaikh bhai... with regards

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on June 16, 2012
Dear Shiv Shankar Bhai, I have been missing your comments a lot. I thought
you have abundant Youtube. It is a great honour to have appreciation and
liking from a person of your calibre. It is long list of videos which need
your viewing. Thanks and best regards Mukhtar

Jagdish Pathak on July 22, 2012
I am sorry to say that this song is dubbed on different video of
Madhubala..original song is sung in Jawab movie by Kanandevi herself.on
screen too ..I don't understand what prompted you to mix different
audio-video...!

orientlover1 on July 24, 2012
I think images of Madhubala and Dilip Kumar in the above clip are from some other film and not film Jawab. Madhubala was born in 1933 and was only 8 or 9 at that time.

arvin20071 on March 05, 2013
Excellent. But just one small correction if you can do it. The opening
frame should say "Chup" not "Shup".

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on March 05, 2013
Dear Arvin ji, thanks for appreciating. Actually, this is one of the first
videos I compiled. The word "shup" has been now part of the video, which
cannot be replaced. Best regards Mukhtar

LonelySea79 on May 02, 2013
Please dont merge different audio and video as it will destroy the fact..

Venkat Warren on May 05, 2013
My mom used to sing this lovely song when I was a little boy ! Great
memories! Thanks. Venkat.

gopal sinha on May 25, 2013
Beautiful..

Raj T on May 10, 2014
So nostalgic--in my childhood used to hear this -sheer delight ,listening
pleasure and great lyrics,Many thanks

sajan jaypee on June 12, 2014
very beautiful collections of songs Mukhtarbhai. thanks.

Vinayak Mahajan on July 15, 2014
tmjatala says films are SINGHAR and TARANA. what was the cast of film
singhar and other credentials ? if somebody knows please post

Harbans Sahni on October 18, 2014
what a heavenl voice. memories from childhood. Chacha Gangavishan used to
recite in the mornings

Mukesh Verma on November 13, 2014
DEAR READERS JIS WAQT KANAN DEVI BAHUT HI CHHOTI THIS US GARIBI KE DINO
ME APNI MAA KA OR APNA PET BHARNE KE LIYE UNKE EK RISHTEDAR NE USKO FILM ME
KAAM DILAYA US WAQT USE 25 RUPEES MILE THE LEKIN KAAM DILANE WALE NE US
CHHOTI SI BACHHI SE JHOOT BOLA AUR USE SIRF RS.5\- DIYE JO UN DINO US
HAALAT ME UNKE LIYE BAHUT T HE AUR BAAD ME TO KANAN DEVI KO MUHMANGI KIMAT
MILNE LAGI TIME TIME KI BAAT HAI FILMI DUNIYA JITNI RANGEEN HAI UTNI HI
DARD BHARI HAI...K K VERMA PALAM NEW DELHI

Hasmukh Jhaveri on December 17, 2014
melodious song.

SKKITU Fremont on December 21, 2014
Kanan Devi is superb in singing and expressions. However, she got
overshadowed by other singers like Lata Mangeshker and Asha Bhonsley,
though she could act well and sing well too. Same way Zubaida Begum's
Punjabi songs are classics and superb but she got overshadowed by Noor
Jahan as a singer.

Bazlur Rahman on March 24, 2015
She is very beautiful here. Today most actors and actresses are used all
sorts of enhancing stuffs, but still look plastic models

sudhir vikram Bhargava on May 31, 2015
ECSTATIC .

Zahir Ahmed on November 10, 2015
This is the greatest song of all times. Reminds me of my childhood . The
innocent and the simplest culture of my country..INDIA.
ZAHIR AHMED

babu chitalya on November 18, 2015
This is for Mr,Vinayak Mahajan, who wonders about the casting. Actually the
song was from Jawab(1942). I think it was not from Singhar. The cast of
Jawab(1942) was Ahindra Choudry, Kanan Devi, Jamuna, P.C.Barua, and some
more.