V. Siddhartha on May 06, 2009
After grading papers, I was ready for some joy. A sister-like friend's
recovery from a nasty flu,a fresh cup of tea, a French pastry, and now this
song-- all this makes me feel anew that God is in His Heaven and life is
good down here. The old record is a bit scratchy, but the sweetness of
Lataji's voice under Roshan's wonderful baton, triumphs like a
crystal-clear brook running over and around all the minor rocks in its way.
A lovely end to my workday, Zaidi Saheb. Thank you.

IMIRZA777 on May 07, 2009
Zaidi Saheb Sham Ko Kiuen Lahore Yaad Kera Dia... Thanks Chamogaa Gi for
forwarding it to me...

Maina on May 08, 2009
Thank You Very much for sharing this beautiful Gem and Many thanks to Zaidi
Sahab too for this fantastic post ! Really appreciated !! Lata Ji's Voice
is alwats very sweet to hear :) Thanks once again ! Regards, Dr.Maina

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on May 10, 2009
Your active contribution of songs to the YT every now and then is a matter
of great pleasure. While posting songs of 'Jawani ki hawa" you have not
included "Bahar leke aaye" by Asha. Perhaps you have kept it for a second
surprise to the viewers, but please don't keep them waiting too long. Yes,
Lahore is one of the finest cities of the world. Please come by, if you
have any associations here and be my guest. Best Regards.

V. Siddhartha on May 10, 2009
Oh, what a warm-hearted message! Inshallah, one hopes one can get together
with fellow music lovers and thank them in person for the joy they spread
around. And it would, of course, be a delight to see Lahore, the beautiful
city so closely connected to my own parents' and grandparents' lives in the
past. Thank you so much again, Zaidi Saheb.

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on May 10, 2009
Dear Chamogaaji My reply has gone to the bottom due to default settings/or
perhaps my ignorance. However, your comment has reminded me of the song
"Kal kal chhal chhal behti jaon" from the film "Samrat Chandargupt'. This
is how you sort of create music or spearhead with your choice of words.
Whenever you visit India, please come to Lahore for sometime, and be my
guest. Thank you, regards, Qasim Zaidi

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on May 10, 2009
Dear Chamogaaji/ Dr.Maina1900 This is in continuation of my reply.Thank you
for liking the song which is really a wonderful composition. Even the hum
and scratchy noises in such songs, do not appear so disagreeable to the
ear, because of their association with our childhood memories. Most of the
78 RPM records those days, used to be a bit worn out and played on spring
loaded manual gramophone machines. One felt proud and privileged for owning
that equipment, too

rumahale on May 14, 2009
Really beautiful song with powerful lyrics . Thanks for the upload.

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on May 14, 2009
Thanks for liking the song.

raqib56 on July 25, 2009
aaj mere anchal se kiun laaj lipat'ti jae

dhani chunar mori hae re,
janay kahan urri jaey re

kia mas'hoor-kun dhun he !!!
mazah agaya

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on July 28, 2009
Thanks for the comment.

Shrikant Talageri on September 04, 2009
Great, rare and beautiful song. Thanks.

saz9297 on December 15, 2009
Zaidi Saheb i dont know where i was. just going on your channel saw this
beautiful song. listened after a very very long time. other beautiful song
from the same film MADHU -- Bata do Koee Kaun gali gae shaam. of course
heart touching. thanks and regards

studer3500 on August 05, 2010
thank you for posting this lovely song.

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on August 05, 2010
@studer3500 thanks for appreciating this song.

Vikas Naikwade on March 25, 2011
MADHU (1959) KARAN DIWAN, MEENA KUMARI, JAGDISH SETHI, KUMKUM, SALIM BOSE,
SUNDER Produced By: MAYA ART PICTURES Directed By: G. MUKHERJEE & S.
BANNERJEE Music By: ROSHAN Dear Zaidiji, what a song you have uploaded. I
think after Anil Biswasji, Roshan was one who really utilise Lata's voice
as well as nurtured his voice. What do you think ?

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on March 25, 2011
@vikasvn1971 It is a great song indeed and Roshan was a brilliant MD.
Thanks.

TheAnupam777 on July 17, 2011
Wallah what a song by Lataji ! Can you please upload some Lata hits from S-J's 'Patrani' direct from 78 rpm records. The vcd of this film released by Priya is very bad, quality-wise. Thanks.

TheAnupam777 on July 17, 2011
Mohataram Zaidi saheb. Aadaab. Wallah what a song by Lataji ! Can you please upload some Lata hits from S-J's 'Patrani' direct from 78 rpm records. The vcd of this film released by Priya is very bad, quality-wise. Thanks.

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on July 17, 2011
@TheAnupam777 Right now I do not have these records but I will try to find
them out. Thanks.

reverseswing on July 17, 2011
Zaidi saheb, I'm sure that Your fans would like to hear your instrumental
version of these two beautiful songs from old film PATRANI. 1. Kabhi to
Aa.Oh sapnaon mein aanewaley kabhi to aa 2. Arey koi aayey.Gori ki
payal baaje You are doing great job zaidi saheb. Keep it up Thank you very
much for your time and consideration. Regards, Yawar

Pransukh Patel on November 21, 2011
What a classic! So nostalgic, my mind is longing for those years... Thank
you so much for putting this gem on!

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on November 21, 2011
@TheJaikishanS Thanks.

CVTME on March 28, 2012
Wonderful song and voice ! When I saw the picture in small size before I opened the clip, I could swear it was Manisha Koyrala. But I'm not in the least disappointed of course.

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on March 29, 2012
You are welcome!

Jagjit Singh Ishar on September 16, 2014
It was almost washed down from my memory lane. Thanks Zaidi sahib for
reminding & posting this forgotten melody. Love it like it. Really Roshan
Lal was an excellent composer of very high level & caliber.