Bharat Desai on September 11, 2010
Thanks for your nice response, Suresh ji. Pl. read some comments & you
would know about the video. Best Wishes.

sagardw2004 on November 25, 2010
Because of u, we r able to see such great songs.So no need to say forgive for bad quality.In fact we r thankful for ur sincere effort.keep it up..

Raji Tripathi on February 22, 2011
The video portion is from the move "Ek Saal" starring Ashok Kumar and
Madhubala. The song is Sab kuchhh luta ke hosh men aaye to kya kiya.
Excellent dubbing job!!!

Bharat Desai on February 22, 2011
You are absolutely right. Thanks for compliments & response. Wishes.

NANDI KHANNA on August 12, 2011
A very good rendition by Lata ji,but still lags behind Hemat da.In tandem
songs Lata ji could not outclass her male counterparts,be it Mukesh ji or
Talat saab,who were no match to mighty Lata ji where singing prowess was
concerned,though bitter but that was the truth.

rumahale on September 15, 2011
@NANDIKHANNA Thanks for critical appreciation.

rumahale on October 18, 2011
@sanjitnarwekar Very interesting. Thanks.

crazyoldsongs on November 25, 2011
thanks for the beauty ! listening to it again !

rumahale on December 31, 2011
@crazyoldsongs Absolutely. I too listened it now and experienced that
soothing effect. Thanks for the encouragement.

Moid Hasan on May 14, 2012
Pl,rectify first film of Shakti Samanta was Bahu 1955,not Inspector 1956.

nandu1f on May 26, 2012
Lata at her best. Her rendering the line "hein jisne hume' ye dard diya,
hum usko duanye dete hein. Ye dard dawa ban jayega, ek din jo purana ho'
jaye'..." is so intensely touching. A song to cherish fowever! Thanks
Ramachandra.

rumahale on May 27, 2012
Absolutely. I just listened it and concentrated on lines you mentioned. It
is so true touching. Excellent observation and comments in tune with
quality of the song. Thanks.

Shabbir Rangwala on November 30, 2012
beautiful words

rumahale on November 30, 2012
True. Thank you for the appreciation.

amsharanx on February 07, 2013
An excellent and touching song. I hear it many times.

rumahale on February 08, 2013
Welcome. Thank you for liking.

Vimla Sharma on April 15, 2013
one of best song i like.thanks

Bharat Desai on April 15, 2013
My Fav too, Sister. Thanks & Good Wishes.

MohammadAli Rupani on April 17, 2013
"Aesa na ho tere ronese mahefil me tamasha hojae" What a meaningful song .
Hemant sahab ki awaz to bas ruladeti hay.

Many many thanks for uploading.

satyendra bindal on June 17, 2013
this reminds me of an old friend Aftab who used to CRY this song

Bharat Desai on June 17, 2013
It is really heart touching song...

Tarsem Lal Gercha on July 27, 2013
I have got this song in my collections in India, This is very wondeful and
heart touching song and is fett from the core of my heart , the song sung
by Hemant Kumar. beyond the expressions Pathar Ka Zigar Bhe Sun Ke Jesae Ik
Bar Tou Pani Hoe Jae. absolutely wonderful . Thanks for uploading the vedio

Bharat Desai on July 27, 2013
Yes, A Rare Gem with Remix Vid as original was not available... Thanks &
Good Wishes.

Amit Kumar Ray Chowdhury on August 01, 2013
What a song . Salute to Hemanta Babu .

Bharat Desai on August 01, 2013
Yes, an all time classic.

dsapkota on August 08, 2013
one of my super duper songs, millions of tx for sharing it.

Bharat Desai on August 10, 2013
Yes, An All time classic. Thanks & Good Wishes.

Bharat Desai on October 31, 2013
Yes, each line touches us to the core. Thanks & Good Wishes.

Neil Bird on October 31, 2013
Hello Bharat, i like the melody of this old classic and thinking of
learning on my harmonium but what is the gist of the meaning of this song
if you could be so kind to tell me?

Bharat Desai on November 03, 2013
It is an old classic in dual version. The female version is equally
touching. It is about a disappointed lover telling his Heart to sing such a
song that my grief becomes a peace of joy for the world at the same time it
shakes up my stone hearted Lover. I give good wishes to her. This pain will
become medicine if it becomes even one day old. I request you, o my inner
pain, let there be no tears in my eyes when I sing, else it will become a
Scene in gathering...

Bharat Desai on November 03, 2013
How do yo you like it, Neil? Om Shanti & Good Wishes...

Neil Bird on November 03, 2013
Its a lovely melody that they don't seem to make these days. I suppose the
meaning once a Bk can mean something different and i like the idea of
finding a purpose in sorrow and a way to change it into something of
benefit. Thanks very much Bharat for taking the time. I like hemantji. Om
shanti

Subhash Kothari on April 20, 2014
What a sweet song with the meaningful wordings. I like this song.

satinder broca on September 19, 2014
Dear Desai,
Thanks for uploading one of my most favorite songs
even though you hsve very cleverly used the visuals of a song SAB KUCHH
LUTA KE HOSH MEIN AAYE TO KYAKIYA by Talat Mehmood from Devendra Goel's
memorable film EK SAAL.
-satinder broca

satinder broca on September 19, 2014
Sorry, Deven Sharma ji,
I posted my comment without reading your earlier post.
-satinder broca

Gulabchand Punjabi on October 27, 2014
AAWAJ MERI TOOTE DIL KI...DUNIYA KE DILON KO TADFAA DE .
.PATHTHAR KA JIGAR HAIN UNKE LIYE...
.EKBAAR TO PAANI HO JAAYE.
YE AAH MERI DUNIYA KE LIYE
.. KHUSHIYON KA
TARANA HO JAAYE..DIL CHHED KOI AISA NAGMA...

Gulabchand Punjabi on October 27, 2014
AAWAJ MERE TOOTE DIL KI DUNIYA KE DILON KO TADFA DE ..PATHTHAR KA JIGAR
BHI UNKE LIYE EKBAAR TO PAANI HO JAAYEN .VERY HEART TOCHING LINES IN
SWEET VOICE OF LATAJI ...

Hasmukh Jhaveri on June 06, 2015
very sweet and melodious song by hemantkumar

Surender Bhutani on June 27, 2015
A lovely composition of Hemantda. In the beginning Hemant promoted S.H.
Bihari. Later on Bihari went to O.P. Nayyar who used his talent very well.