jasbongy on January 08, 2010
Wow, khalid Bhai, beautiful song,sung so well by Asha ji. Your video
presentation is as usual brilliant.10***************** With respect. Sarla
Didi.

cheecheepia on January 08, 2010
Sarla ji you may know this ghazal was sung by ghula ali ji around 30 years
back and asha ji did great job by singing in her style. Thanks for your
kind words.regards: khalid

V. Siddhartha on January 08, 2010
Thanks, Khalidji. Ashaji is Ashaji and we all love her voice, but to be
candid, in this rendition her voice falters a bit over several notes and is
not of the high professional quality that we associate with her. It may
have been a recent recording. She is about 75 now, so the effect of age is
beginning to show. Still I adore her. How many can sing even this well in
their 70s, after all? Thanks for the post with your fine creative montage
again.

cheecheepia on January 08, 2010
Thanks vipan ji!!! Generally she did good job but as you described age is
big factor and this song is not old.Not bad in her 70's. Thanks for
watching.

KhalidAsgharRadioPak on January 08, 2010
mediocre rendition. Thanks to "cheecheepia " a YouTube channel for up load.
Khalid Asghar, former Controller/ Station Director, Lahore (08-01-2010)

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on January 08, 2010
Dear all! I think age has not influenced Asha ji that much. She is quite
fit, far more than people of her age. In my view she has sung this ghazal
casually and has made some unnecessary variations, just for the heck of it,
which have reduced the quality of her rendition a bit below our
expectations.

cheecheepia on January 08, 2010
Thanks for watching zaidi sahib... As i said not bad in her 70's.

cheecheepia on January 08, 2010
Thanks for watching!!!

bhupidhillon on January 08, 2010
Filmy song singers cannot do justice to ghazals. In ghazals emotions and
feelings are very important.

cheecheepia on March 24, 2010
Yes my boy this ghazal was sung by ghulam ali ji long before you were born
in early 1970's LOL, She is versatile singer no doubt about that and she is
performing in my town April 4th Easter long weekend, i like that word
SHAHEB instead sahib cuz thats bengali accent, you are a nice boy.thanks
for watching and your new upload was great.

shahid aly on September 12, 2010
tassuvar khanum's version in black and white is recorded in her prime and
best

Anandaroop Bhattacharya on April 06, 2013
An absolute murder of the original!

AlainBeauvoir on June 08, 2013
This completely ruined the original. I can't believe Asha ji would even
sing something like this.