yuanyuanyuanyin on August 07, 2010
Thank you my dear friend Dr. Kamath for sending the video to me too.
Nice performance, the third part is much nicer, the Flute part.
Congratulations!

Bhupinder Pujji on August 07, 2010
KYA BAAT HAI BILKUL FLAWLESS U DONE IT SO WELL CONGRATS KEEP SINGING THANKS
FOR SHARING LAGE RAHO MUNNA BHAI BHUPINDER

jasbongy on August 07, 2010
Dr. Kamath ji, in each part of this beautiful,soulful,touching song, you
have put your best performance,so all are very impressive. But still i like
the 2nd. part the best. As i prefer thin,soothing sound,i feel that on your
2nd. part.of the song. 1. On first part though the song is sad i enjoyed
your singing it with emotions of ''dard.'' 2. This one my fav.It very,very
soothing to ears.Thumbs Up. 3.This is good but 2nd. is much better
according to me. Which is Your Fav.? W.R. Sarla

nrkamath43211 on August 07, 2010
@sabnavees Dear Sabnavees, Thanks a Lot for oyur prompt appreciative
comment. Regards, Dr. Kamath

nrkamath43211 on August 07, 2010
@yuanyuanyuanyin My Dear Friend Yuan, Thank you very much for your prompt
response and Great Compliments.Nice to know you liked Part 3. With Best
Wishes, Dr. Kamath

kuckudk on August 07, 2010
Hello dr Kamath Aap ne to hamen pashopesh mein daal diya.Which Part is best
is difficult to decide, still if you insist I will say that last piece of
Flute is very impressive. Your vocal Dukhi Man mere is also very
sentimentally sung with full emotions. You have given us a Family pack
without any cost , Thank you very much.I liked it very much.

nrkamath43211 on August 07, 2010
@bhupindersinghpujji Dear Bhupinder Ji, Thanks a BILLION for your wonderful
comment. You made my DAY! Kind Regards, Dr. Kamath

nrkamath43211 on August 07, 2010
@jasbongy Sarla Ji, Thank you once again so so so much for your high
appreciation. Thanks for letting me know in details about how you felt
after listening all 3 parts. I know you like thin sound of Flute and that
is why you liked Part 2 better than other 2 parts. Although Flute is my
most favorite instrument, over here I liked Part 1 or the Vocal singing
because like you said I could express "DARD" through the words and Flute
cannot utter words and plays notes Regards with Respect Kamath

nrkamath43211 on August 07, 2010
@kuckudk Dear Sharma Ji, Thanks a BILLION for your LOVELY LOVELY Comment.
Aap Ki Comment Padhkar Dil Ekdam Khush Huwa. Mogambo Khush Huwa. You are
absolutely right, among 3 parts as per you you liked Flute piece Part 3,
however I liked my Vocal piece or Part 1 better than other 2 parts since in
Part 1, I could express full emotions through the words. Thank you once
again for your prompt comment. Regards, Dr. Kamath

Sanjay Sahay on August 07, 2010
well sung khoobsoorat

nrkamath43211 on August 07, 2010
@sanjaysahay Dear Sanjay Bhai, Thank you very much for your high
appreciation. Regards, Dr. Kamath

ajay vijh on August 07, 2010
nicely sung, and beautifully played, I liked first and second parts ,
CHEERS ( PL DONT BE DUKHI SO FREQUENTLY, HA HA )

nrkamath43211 on August 07, 2010
@ajayvijh Dear Ajay Bhai, Thanks a Lot. Hamesha "Mastwaale" Songs Gaane Ke
Baad Socha Ke Aaj Ek Dukhi Gaana Ho Jaay Aur Phir "Dukhi Man Mere" Yaad Aa
Gaya. I am glad you liked Part 1 and 2. Regards, Dr. Kamath

chotasagar on August 07, 2010
Hello Dr Kamath, I look forward to weekend to be entertained by fellow
friends and artists on YT. I am not going to differentiate between each
section of your performance and all I will say each and every sections was
very expressive and emotional and I thouroughly enjoyed listening to your
performance as always. My Good Wishes and Best Regards..Siraj

nrkamath43211 on August 08, 2010
@chotasagar Dear Siraj Bhai, Thanks for your appreciation and for giving
equal marks to all 3 sections. That is very nice of you. I appreciate your
valuable time to visit and comment so wonderfully. CHEERS, Dr. Kamath

Shiv Shanker on August 08, 2010
Bahut sunder Dr.Kamath ji... you have sung Kishore Kumar who was different
when he sang this song... later when he was yoodling... I did not like
that... your passion of old golden era song is commendable... keep going..
regards SS

nrkamath43211 on August 08, 2010
@eddie21y21 Dear Shiv Shanker Ji, Thanks a ZILLION for your outstanding
comment. Yes. I love this emotional song very much. The lyrics of this song
are very very meaningful and are true even today when we look at the
society be it India or USA, it does not matter. The lyrics of this song
send a very strong message to the selfish society. But I and you know very
well that society will continue to act in selfish way. No amount of songs
like this will change society Rgds, Dr. Kamath

Shiv Shanker on August 08, 2010
@nrkamath43211 I agree wtih you completely... regards Shiv Shanker

Sablu Mukesh on August 08, 2010
Dr Sahab, Pranam aapko Soulful singing part-1 Excellent and melodious flute
playing part-2 Outstanding and very spiritual sound of baas flute part-3
Overall I immensely enjoyed. I also liked your vocal part.

johnsandrabaitali on August 08, 2010
Waw..Kamath ji. You have done a wonderful job in all the 3 parts. Just
great !!!. Kishore Kumar is my favourite. Thanks to choose this mindblowing
song. We enjoyed a lot !!!!!!. Regards from Sandra & John.

nrkamath43211 on August 08, 2010
@johnsandrabaitali Dear John and Sandra, Thanks A ZILLION for your Great
Great Compliment. Glad to know you both enjoyed. Regards to Both of You.
Dr. Kamath

nrkamath43211 on August 08, 2010
@mrsablu Dear Sablu Bhai, Thanks a ZILLION for your outstanding comment.
You made my LIFE once again! Regards, Dr. Kamath

Pradeep Sharma on August 09, 2010
Dear Kamath Ji, First Of All You have Chosen A Superb Soulful Song From
Kishore Da And Secondly Superb Vocal Rendition In Your Sweet Voice, After
That You Have Played Melodious Flute, I Think Base Flute Is Always More
"DUKHI" Then Normal Flute.

nrkamath43211 on August 10, 2010
@sharmapradeep207 Dear Pradeep Bhai, Sirf Aap hi Ki Comment Ka Intazaar
Tha. Bahot Dhanyvaad Itni Acchi Comment Ke Liye. Yes. I tried to put my
whole soul into the song. Yes. Base Flute sound is always deep and
meditative. With Best Wishes, Dr. Kamath

harishkainth on August 10, 2010
Superb song u choose Dr. Kamath & sing very nice too..After that u played
very nice on flute..Great job!

nrkamath43211 on August 10, 2010
@harishkainth Dear Harish Bhai, Thank you very very much for your
compliments. Regards, Dr. Kamath

R Nanjappa on October 29, 2013
Dr.Sab, It was en experience listening to your singing of this eternal gem
and also your two versions on the flute. it is one of the best that Kishore
ever sang, in his original golden voice.it is also one of those great songs
which can be enjoyed all the better if heard alone, not necessarily watched
. It has such an eternal quality that it can be rendered, like a classical
piece, by one who can identify with its philosophy, its emotion, its
melody. Jagjit Singh too sang it. You have done great

R Nanjappa on October 29, 2013
I want to share with you something I heard about this song. It seems once
Kishore was depressed at lack of opportunities and was thinking of leaving
Bombay. One day Burmanda called him home, but Kishore said he would not
sing. It seems Burmanda said: 'Who is asking you to sing.Just come for
khana'. When Kishore came,Burmanda just told him: 'What do you mean you
will not sing? Sing this-I composed it for you'. And that song is Dukhi man
mere. Is this why this has that unexplainable something?

nrkamath43211 on October 30, 2013
WELCOME TO MY CHANNEL Nanjappa Ji. Thanks for your input about this song,
Kishore Da and Burman Da. Kishore Kumar rightfully said that this is his
the most favorite among all the songs he sang for Bollywood. With Best
Wishes, Dr. Kamath

R Nanjappa on October 30, 2013
Thanks Dr. for your quick response. Two of my other Kishore favourites are:
'Wo meri taraf yun' from Kafila and 'Chota sa ghar hoga' from Naukri. ( The
sad version of the latter song by Hemant Da is also moving.) I wonder if
these too can be rendered on the flute.