Aashutosh Singh on March 26, 2009
Shubha..YOU ARE THE BEST!!!

syedmshahid on November 09, 2009
Shubha's singing + ghalib's poetry has mesmerising effect!

madhurverma1 on July 07, 2010
Though this song is excellently sung by many famous singers including Abida
Parveen but the ecstacy in Shubha Mudgal's voice is unparralel.. So
mesmerizing that one doesnot wish to come out of this amazing feeling and
the beautiful effect of this feeling gets multiplied if one can relate
himself with the feeling of Chitrangada Singh in this movie.. No doubt an
amzing work in Hindi Cinema !!

MonsieurVerbose on October 01, 2011
Hauntingly Melodious. Love it toDeath

sanamo86 on January 02, 2012
@madhurverma1 I always thought this song is a reflection of shiney ahujha
devotional love for chitrangda

sugandh sood on January 04, 2012
@sanamo86 true...

madhurverma1 on January 16, 2012
@sanamo86 In the major portion of movie.. Shiney Ahuja is shown as a
shallow and greedy personality with individual centric motives.. But
Chitrangda is a personality who is in search of a meaningful life..
Ghalib's beautiful narration and Shubha Mudgal's ecstatic voice (according
to me) fits into her personality !! :)

Rahul Apte on January 29, 2012
So Mesmerizing , i believe Shubha Mudgal ji has sung it better than Jagjit
Sir!! Like if you think so.

sanamo86 on February 04, 2012
@madhurverma1 I agree with you that Shiney is a the personality you
describe. However his love 4 chitrangda is not. Despite knowing he will
never have her he devotes himself 2 her. His love for her is without
condition & @ each stage he gets rejected by her. To the extent of
personally rescuing KK (the husband of the 1 he loves) for the happiness of
his love. Whereas all the other love in the film is conditional, on how
much the other person loves them. so infact shineys love is the deepest

sanamo86 on February 04, 2012
@madhurverma1 translation of the song: I have a thousand desires, all
desires worth dying for, Though many of my desires were fulfilled, majority
remained unfulfilled. Fits perfectly with Shineys character. All his
shallow, greedy desires become fulfilled: out all all the characters in the
film, he becomes the richest, most powerfull, most influential, however
they meant nothing to him because his true desire (for chitrangda to love
him) remain unfulfilled

Khush Fehm on March 23, 2012
Kachda - please fix the lyrics. The word 'phir' is incorrectly spelled
'fir'' in your lyrics. Remember that a 'phool' is a flower, while af

sanamo86 on October 11, 2012
I appreciate your interpretation & it makes sense, but for some reason I
feel this song is Shiney Ahujas feelings, reason being is he out of all the
main characters is the only one who achieves the financial & political
status he spent his whole life searching for (bahut nikale mere armaa.N ),
yet constantly feels unsatisfied because the one woman he loves doesnt love
him (lekin phir bhii kam nikale)

Rai Bahadur Singh (Niff T) on April 25, 2014
Psychedelic.

Neha Kadam on October 26, 2014
usee ko dekh kar jeete hain jis kaafir pe dam nikle..