Dee Thakore on March 15, 2009
your choice is always great! thanks for upload.

ib422000 on March 15, 2009
Wah, Sr. Sahib! These pictures are absolutely priceless, and song goes
without saying. Thanks.

bhupidhillon on March 16, 2009
That was very nice. Thank you.

lovehumanity on March 16, 2009
aik ajeeb si udaasi hay is geet mein Atma sahab ki awaz mein.. which is
just perfectly suiting the lyrics hes singing.. kabhi kabhi gaatay gaatay
aap ko pata bhi nahi chalta aur aap kay andar ka dard khamoshi say baahar
aa jata hay aur uska ihsaas us waqt hota hay jab aapko lagta hay kay hua to
kuchh nahi magar aankhen bheeg gai hain..shayad kuchh geet dil par choat
khayay baghair gayay nahi ja saktay :(

Dee Thakore on March 16, 2009
I know listeners do feel agony of singer. Very simple example; If I can
name a few in western music during 1930's lots people committed suicide
after listening 'Gloomy Sunday' a Hungarian song. In 1941 Billie Holiday
made English version of Gloomy Sunday.

Dee Thakore on March 16, 2009
In 1951 Eila Pellinen made same song in Finnish. In 1983: Jacques Calonne
made same song in French. in 2003: Priscilla Chan with Cantonese, made
"Gloomy Sunday" in 2004 Mc Sniper made in Korean. also few remix too. in
2009 Aliyah Hussain and Paris Jones of Canada used that song. in 2006
American cabaret singer Emilie Autumn made a song called "The Art of
Suicide". It's up to us how we project the song,

Kirit9745 on March 17, 2009
Credit mst also be given to O.P. Nayyar for composing sch a melodious tune,
this was perhaps his first film, and he sounds so mature ! OP was so much
infatuated with K.L.Saigal that when his time came, he chose the voice best
resembling that of saigal.OP has also composed A few excellent private
songs in the voice of N.L. Puri who also sounds very much like
Saigal.Anyway ,thanks for posting the song, dr.ji.

Muhammad Jamil on March 20, 2009
one of the very old song i listened to after many many years and the melody
, the song all came alive as it was yesterday.Dr Sahib thank you very much
for giving us the opportunity to listened to this beautiful song .

V. Siddhartha on March 22, 2009
Thanks, Doc, for trying to preserve another part of CHA's legacy on YT due
to the ominous presence of Rajshri Media on the horizon.The very simplicity
of such renditions combined with the inimitable depth of the voice makes
them especially valued. They go to the commanding heights of music where
the rarest geniuses dwell.

V. Siddhartha on March 22, 2009
And ,Doc, I commend you also for putting up those lovely pictures. The
playful interaction with soft bunnies between CHA and Talat Mehmood is
especially precious, for it shows that thankfully neither gave up his "
inner child" in adulthood.The image projects sweet innocence and purity in
personality.

lovehumanity on March 22, 2009
yeah very right :)

teen49 on May 05, 2009
beautiful song.lovely voice ..thank u very much...lovehumanity.. can u
plz up load some jag mohan 'songs ...thanks in advance

teen49 on May 05, 2009
thanks for uploading such a beautiful song.Awesome...can u plz upload some
lovely songs of jagmohan..in advance thanks

IMIRZA777 on June 30, 2009
Thanks. Bukhari sahab.

lovehumanity on June 30, 2009
Credit surely goes to you too Mirza Ji :)

rameshvannadil on August 12, 2009
yes indeed . u z it all right sir. thanks a lot. to bring his memmory in
here. prretam ann milo was a great song. and one imitable person for
saigaal ssab was only CHA. great are those days.

MrEdmontonian on July 13, 2010
do you his famous song...AAJ KI RAATH GHUME YAAR MAIN SHIDAT HE BUHTH

saleem4771 on December 06, 2010
very beautiful verses with a melodious voice has brought sweet memoriess.thanx alot
saleem

Tusharbhatia20 on January 29, 2011
this is the first recorded fil song of Ustad O P Nayyar sahab!

orientlover1 on April 19, 2011
What was full name of C.H Atma?

NANDI KHANNA on April 24, 2011
@orientlover1 c.h,atmas full name was ATMA H. CHAINANI.born KHARADAR area
of KARACHI on 10th december 1923,he passed away on 6th
december1975.(YESTERDAYS MELODIES TODAYE MEMORIES by Manek Premcand)

NANDI KHANNA on April 24, 2011
@orientlover1 c.h.atmas full name was ATMA H. CHAINANI born on 10th
december1923 in KHARADAR area of KARACHI,passed away on 6th dec.1975.

Hargovind100 on August 07, 2012
Wonderfull song with golden voice of my favorite singer ! The comments of
"thecritc102" are so appropiate ! Very few Bollywood music lovers are
familiar with this great singer. It was a real loss to the Bollywood music
world.

khukuchow9 on November 23, 2012
What a beautiful song. It sounds so good with so much of pathos. khukuchow9

BOB IYER on May 27, 2013
.. Janab Atma sahib key awaaz mein woh soz hai jo shayiri kay alfazon
mein jaan phoonk deta hai. Kaash har koi gulukar inkey naqshey qadam par
chalkar apni awaz mein woh soz paida karta jis say shayiri ka maza dobala
ho jata!

Indu Puri on August 13, 2013
is bewafaa jahaan mein wafaa dhoondhte rahe naadaan the kitne ham bhi ye
kyaa dhoondhte rahe har raastaa agarche teraa raastaa na thaa har raaste
mein teraa pataa dhoondhte rahe..waaaaah

Zulfiqar Bukhari on July 16, 2014
Kia khoub surat geet kia aadiegi kia dhun wah