V. Siddhartha on January 22, 2010
A sweet tribute to GD by Lataji, but the voice at the higher notes is
sometimes too sharp and the pathos is undermined a bit. I am afraid this
song really belongs to GD and to no one else. My comment doesn't detract
from the overall greatness of Lataji. Thanks, Ajay.

salil dixit on May 31, 2010
geeta version is better than lata version . thanks, for uploading this
version also in video .

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on May 31, 2010
@salildixit67 thanks Salil

passion689 on June 07, 2010
This song simply puts you in a trance, permeating deep in soul, particularly if you are already in a pensive mood ! Aptly remixed and played along an overwhelming background clip Geeta Dutt's undulating voice creates ripples in the high sea...at the same time so soothing and calming for a disjointed soul. Thanks Mukhtar for this outstanding presentation. Your other remix on Nayyera Noor is also superb.

Bharat Desai on June 09, 2010
Thanks for sharing this Gem of a song with Gem of your creayivity in
compiling the Vid. Best Wishes.

chandrashekharjain on June 10, 2010
SUPERB video creation on a superb song. Hema Malini clips from film 'Meera'
and other clips have been suitably placed.This version in Geeta Dutt voice
is certainly much more impressive than Lata's version. Congratulations to
Mr Mukhtar on his commendable work. A version in Hemant Kumars voice is
still awaited from Mukhtar Bhai.

Vipin283 on June 14, 2010
Congrat Lataji also upload this memorable song Greate composition/lyrics/artist
Thanks. Requwest to all pl. more and more people lisen this song.

rumahale on August 04, 2010
Great presentation. I fully agree with what is mentioned in the
introduction. This could well have suited as tribute to Geeta Dutt. Thanks.

rajivsood25 on October 29, 2010
Wah , Mukhtarjee , you are great, this my always my first song, your
presentation is always best. Wah

madhubala2009 on November 09, 2010
I have nothing to add to the eloquent comments of my fellow Mukhtar fans:)
This is really so powerful.It would have been a fabulous combination,Geeta and Hema,and you just did it! Thanks again!
There are some songs from the film Zalzala,made by Pankaj Mullick,in my favorites;these sound to me like Geeta at her best.Or maybe you already made a"vision" from these?If not,please listen..

Vipin283 on November 15, 2010
Thanks for beautiful song upload on You Tube if some have vedio pl. upload Hemantda and geetaji sing this gem, no words for describe,all time outstanding, remember old time Radio Ceylone one programme DO RANG DO PAHELU DO GEET fantistic songs broadcast at time now a days pure Vahiyat songs - no wording-no music for long the wants only make money- don't care - let me know since 15/20 yrs, which songs will publuc wants to listen, only old is god.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on November 15, 2010
@Vipin283 Thank you Vipinji, for your kind comments on my video, I greatly
appreciate it. It makes me feel good when people like you appreciate and
enjoy old and forgotten songs. Only those can give such comments who have
knowledge and taste in good music. Best regards

nandu1f on March 25, 2011
Wonderful montage for an exquisite song in Geeta Dutt's haunting voice.
Thanks for your creations, Mukhtar ji.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on March 26, 2011
@nandu1f Thanks Nandu Ji I am thankful for the nicest lexes for my creation
on this rare and matchless song. Your nice words have brightened my
efforts. May you continue to enjoy good music in good health, harmony &
wisdom for years to come! Mukhtar

kabeera88888 on January 03, 2012
Very beautiful song from bad ban.

Surendra Mane on March 08, 2012
Mukhtarji, lot of thanks for uploading this masterpiece, which i used to
listen since my childhood. Great Geeta Dutta.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on March 09, 2012
@Surendra7453 Thanks Surendra ji , this marvelous song is also my favorite
since childhood. It introduced me to good music. Mukhtar

saz9297 on March 12, 2012
my comments same as i gave on same song by hemant kumar. would have been
nice to see madhubala or kamni kaushal in VDO. anyhow thank you

ratnakar tripathy on April 22, 2012
thanks and no thanks Mr Mukhtar. wherever i look for this song, you have
mucked up the visuals. must make u feel good you are all over. but only as
an avoidable type, rest assured. be careful with touching. some things just
wilt when u touch them hard!

arvind ketkar on December 04, 2012
wah kya baat hai beautiful and appropriate conversion of video thanks a lot
god bless you n ur friends n family

arvin20071 on January 11, 2013
Beautiful song with very skillful video editing. Thank you for the treat.

Tarsem Lal Gercha on July 28, 2013
What a beautiful , nice and appropreate translation of the lyrics, each
word is heart touching and penitrates in to the heart I know probabaly that
the sweet singing bird Papiha does not take water directly but gets it from
rain drops to quinch his thurst after flying into the cloudy sky and
adoping opposite its tilting direction opening its mouth in a wish that it
will catch water drops.I. e. Why, Peasy Papehe Ne Aas The Baandhi Ud Gae
Baadal Aa Gae Aandhi. Thanks a lot for uploading this gem.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on July 29, 2013
Thanks Gercha ji for the nice words about translation of this marvellous
song. This song simply puts you in a trance, permeating deep into the soul,
particularly if you are already in a meditative mood. thanks and best
regards Mukhtar

satyen bindal on February 23, 2014
Great tribute to Hemant Da,GD,and Timir Baran

Bipin Sinha on January 28, 2015
Kya kahoon is gane par,shabd nahin hain. Kahan gaye ve din jab fija me ye
geet lahra rahe the.

Atul Kothari on August 29, 2015
Thanks Mukhtar sab.