harpreetkaur2009 on August 12, 2009
Both very great singers Mhd Rafi & Mahendra Kapoor

Afg Power on April 24, 2010
Allah bless Mohammad Rafi Sahab's soul!

RealMusicKing on June 25, 2010
Originally, Naushad picked Rafi and Talat for this song. Manoj refused to be playbacked by Talat. Despite all the pleas from producer, Naushad and Dilip Kumar, Talat was replaced by Mahendra Kapoor. But Talats voice remained on the Master Tape at HMV.

Rafi Habib on October 29, 2010
MASTERPEICE ))) this song is a clearer picture of how different was Rafi
sahab's & Mahendra Kapoor's voice was. though MK had followed the footsteps
of RS but the Master was miles ahead of him. MK had achieved a very good
level in singing though & would always have a special place in our hearts.
it is sad that nobody remembers MK ji. his many songs with MD Ravi &
Kalyanji Anandji r gr8 contribution to the lovely Hindi Film Music..

fsagar711 on February 21, 2011
@RealMusicKing . I love the song more with Talat Mahmood and Rafi sahab.
The combination is deadly.

iqbalgulmemon on February 25, 2011
Wah ! best print & khubsurat song

Noniskia Noni on March 09, 2011
MK just cryin g, Rafi is sweat and melodious

abid malik on May 24, 2011
RAFI SAHAB IS KING OF MELODY ITS NOT POSSIBLE TO COME NEAR HIS LEVEL
...IMPOSSIBLE.

Juvenile Delinquet on November 22, 2011
This song clearly shows the greatness of Muhammad Rafi Sahab. Mahindra
Kapoor tried hard to copy the legendry Rafiji, but failed miserably. In an
interview M.D.O.P.Nayyar said that in most of his songs, he used to be very
bessurra and i had recorded that with me and whenever he would boost that
he sang like Rafi, i would let him hear that besurra song of him. O.P.
Nayyar said thet he clearly told MK that there can never be another Rafi.
Rafi clearly has overshadowed MK, in this song. Rafi GR8

Juvenile Delinquet on November 22, 2011
@zamzamacola! Every body has the right to comment, you narrow-minded freak,
what wrong K.P has narrated, she is right

Bele Bel on January 02, 2012
I personally heard that because Talat Mehmood insisted that his voice was
not matching for Mnajo Kumar rather for Dilip kumar so he quited and let
Mahindar kapoor sing this song in the film.

Krishna Paramathma on February 24, 2012
pure pure melody.. two great legendary singers singing one song. how
beautiful it makes. Thanks to Rafisaab, Mahendra Kapoor and OPN for giving
this treasure to us. Hum Abhaari hain unka.. Both Sun and Moon
together...Guru and Shishya... Mahendra Kapoor would have taken enought
troubles and practiced a lot to come to Rafi saab level. as usual Rafi
saab, very cool, down to earth person...

Consultant Anesthesiologist on March 10, 2012
Especially Rafi's clear domination is quite obvious in the second stanzas,
MK can never come even closer to this Legend of Indian Cinema. His voice is
only Melody & Surr, MK must only try ghazals for which his voice is a bit
OK, Rafi subdues every singer he sings with, even Lata feels inferiority
complex while singing with Rafi Sahab

reverseswing on March 23, 2012
It is true that Manoj Kumar didn't accept Talat Mahmood's version of this
duet and MD Naushad yielded to Manoj Kumar's pressure. Manoj wasn't against
Rafi although he preferred Mukesh and Mahindra Kapoor's voices for his
films. I think it is not a good practice to change the singer (once the
song is recorded) on the basis of personal likes and dislikes of actors.
Here in this case both Talat and Mahindra were the victims due to the
unrealistic attitude of Manoj Kumar.

Adam Elijah on March 24, 2012
I am not hndu but do respect them in the bottom of my heart. Feel sorry for
the playboy nation of mohammed who can have 4 wives at the same time and
talk about morality. Still I pray for them without any positive outcome as
per history..

Narasimhan Srinivasan on July 10, 2012
Manoj Kumar was clearly aware that he owed his success to Rafi in his
earlier romantic films including Sawan Ki Ghata where Rafi did all play
back for him. It was because of this success that Manoj Kumar went on to
become an independent producer and director. It is true that Talat,
howsoever great singer he might have been did not have a voice suitng Manoj
Kumar. Manoj Kumar's gratitude to Rafi was proved by the fact that he was
present at Rafi's funeral. Clear hai??

Sharad Bailur on July 22, 2012
I am sorry but if it is a wquestion of music, in my opinion Mahendra Kappor sounds like a caterwauling Tom cat in heat.

AVTAR SINGH BATHAM on October 10, 2012
KISKO KYA MILA HAI MUKADDAR KI BAAT HAI.THIS IS A UNVERSAL TRUTH.

Rarobvi on October 25, 2012
Mahendra Kapoor also has a beautiful voice !! And here Manoj is the god of
actor's

Mustafa Sharafi on April 27, 2013
This is Talat Mehmood's voice dear. it's not Mahendra

Chandrasekharan Nair on January 12, 2014
What a beautiful song which is also sung by Talatji. Great composition.

jpall411 on April 04, 2014
Mohammad rafi was the best singer of all time without question. He will
never be matched. But let's not take away the great talent of Mahendra
kapoor and all the other great singers of that generation. I think MK's
performance in this song is very good.

Jagjit Singh Ishar on December 11, 2014
Talat's voice never suited on Manoj Kumar. I have heard many Talat songs
picturised on Manoj especially Suhag Sindhur. The voice never matched the
character & here in this case the Talat version was very weak so Talat had
to be replaced by Mahinder. It doesn't mean that i dislike Talat, i have
many Talat sung songs as my favorites. But some people are showing
disparage to Mahinder on the basis of religion. The fact remains that
Mahinder Kapoor is one of the best singers of Bollywood & so is the gr8
angel Rafi sahib. Let us not compare singers & give due regard to them.

Sona Satyawan on January 10, 2015
This song originally was sung by mohammed Rafi and Talat Mehmood but the
voice of Talat did not suit to Manoj. So Naushad recorded the song again by
taking Mahendra Kapoor and which suited best to him.
Rajneesh Satyawan Ex.S.D.O