Please rate this song between 1 star and 5 stars (5 stars being the best). Just move your mouse on the stars above and click as per your rating. Your rating will really help us to improve our website.
Comments on song "Saare Jaha Se Achha Hindustan Hamara"
nandu1f on November 22, 2008 Masterpiece, Hemanthji. Brings tears to my eyes. I don't know exactly why.
May be a combination of the beauty of the song and the lofty ideas
expressed, and thinking about our innocence lost from those times, and the
nation's unfulfilled dreams. Don't really want to allude to the low nadir
reached by the politicians since then - not on this site.
vishnukant on April 18, 2009 Thanks for this master piece. This was prayer in my school. My best wishes
to you from Indians
Ehsan Mir Ali Jahan on August 15, 2010 @mrpakithug yes he did. It was written prior to the partition so we use it
because its a good song and he was a great poet.
Haseen Haq on August 20, 2010 How can it be from Allama Iqbal. He will not write "Barbaad kar diya tha
aandhi nain is chaman ko. Gandhi ne is chaman ko.." The real Allama
Iqbal can be found on the wikipedia
DaWanderer on September 07, 2010 Beautiful. just amazing.
Dunddli on September 15, 2010 @mrpakithug nope.. only 1st couplets are from Iqbal.not rest of it..its not
Iqbal's diction.Iqbal's thoughts and wordings were much beautiful than
this..go on wikipedia and compare with Iqbal's Tarana..u ll get answer:)
cheers
Dunddli on September 15, 2010 For all those who think its written by Iqbal. the lyricist of this one is
Raja Mehdi Ali Khan.Music by N. Dutta and Asha Bhosle sang it.. hope it ll
clear to all now..so stop wasting energies on who wrote it :)
acancalan on October 07, 2010 This only glorifies Iqbal more.They need support of Iqbal's work to glorify their own couplets.This is called adulteration like what we have in food and other items.. Hee hee. Pity them, can't present something different and at par with the original work of Iqbal..
vishnukant on December 24, 2010 This was prayer in my school in India. It is great to listen this master
piece.
Rmehtacpa on March 22, 2011 TUNE the BEST which itself invoke Patriotism in the SONG.
hinduempire on April 27, 2011 tumhara mhomad 9 saal ki larki ko chooda, wha wha kiya paak he ye islam
Hindi Geet on June 28, 2011 @Dunddli This song is from the 1959 movie Bhai Bahan, and not from 1969
movie Bhai Bahan. N. Dutta gave music for 1969 movie, and I think G. S.
Kohli was MD in 1959 movie from which this song is taken.
tahermms on July 25, 2011 meet me i will give u a taste of dead.. u say that how can man allowed to marry with 4 female dear a man can handle 4 female ...but how did dropadi able to handled the 5 pandav including bhim
Muhamed Affzal on July 26, 2011 @tahermms Well said...and there are many more to say. Lord Rama's father
had thousand wives. I don't know what is the rationale behind?
Muhamed Affzal on July 26, 2011 @hajirafirasa Well said..I acknowledge your spirits dear.
hinduempire on July 30, 2011 ok so ppl didnt walk fast before islam?
tahermms on July 30, 2011 they do but they didnt know tht by this of them they hv less chances of hrt attack ..
tahermms on July 30, 2011 before islam? islam starts from the day when earth creats
tahermms on August 01, 2011 so.. u agree islam is religion of peace thnks..
bankapursreekanth on August 14, 2011 i DO REMEMBER WELL TODAY, THAT I HAVE SEEN THE FILM DURING 1962 WHEN I WAS IN 9TH STANDARD- I WAS SINGING THIS SONG DURING ALL NATIONAL FESTIVALS.HATS OF SINGERS AND MUSIC DIRECTOR.
vivek phalke on October 02, 2011 simply superb!
vivek phalke on October 02, 2011 simply superb! parvat iske oochne,pyari hai iski nadiyan.aakash main isiki
gujri hazori sadiyan.sajta hai bijliyo par ye ashiyan hamara. veeran kar
diya tha aandhi ne ai chaman ko,dekar lahoo bachaya is chaman ko.jai bharat
,jai gandhi
ShivKumar44 on December 30, 2011 To all MembersYou Tube:I have the movie Bhai Bahen and audio Tape HMV RPG
Patriotic Songs.Bhai Bahen1969 was written by Raja Mehdi Ali Khan and
Music:N.Dutta.I taped the song from Vividh Bharti in1982. I clearly
remember the announcer said"Kalam Allama Iqbal Ka Hai." That song was sung
by Mohd Rafi Asha Bhonsley and chorus."MAJHAB NEHI SIKHATA APASMEIN BAIR
RAKHNA" this Para is not present in movie. School Student used to
sing.There is a scene in the movie Nayee Delhi.Original Poem by IQBAL.
ShivKumar44 on December 30, 2011 Continuation:Father of Talat Mahmood was also a singer. In Lucknow he sung
this song in presence of Allama Iqbal in a variety show. Simply it is not
understood why RMAKhan wrote this song in different way.
Rajeev Ranjan Baisantry on January 25, 2012 Who would have prevented Raja Mehdi Ali Khan to write a different version
of the song, and for that matter why should any one do it.This song was for
a movie sound track; it has to be different than the original song created
by Iqbal Ji. No dis respect has been caused to him by Khan Sahab rajeev 7898
ILoveIndia508 on February 21, 2012 WAKE UP MY DEAR INDIANS!
USE YOUR POWER OF VOTE TO CHANE THIS CORRUPTED GOVERNMENT!
JUST VOTE HONEST, BRAVE, UNCORRUPT POLITICAL LEADERS ONLY!
ILoveIndia508 on February 21, 2012 INDIA NEEDS PM LIKE MR.NARENDRA MODI AND DR.SUBRAMANIAN SWAMY.
BOTH OF THESE POLITICAL LEADERS ARE HONEST, BRAVE, BRILLIANT, UNCORRUPT.
ILoveIndia508 on February 21, 2012 VANDE MATARAM! JAI HIND!
rksbaghel on February 23, 2012 honourable allama iqbal was an artist, who was above castism. he was
bycotted by his community because he translated "gayatri mantra " in urdu.
please be human and let others be human.
forgottenmemories63 on February 28, 2012 Iqbal died in 1938...9 years b4 Pak was created.
Prakash Chawla on June 20, 2012 vandematram
VINOD SINGH Bhandari on September 21, 2012 In spite of its creator's disavowal of it, Saare Jahan Se Achcha has remained popular in India for over a century. Mahatma Gandhi is said to have sung it over a hundred times when he was imprisoned at Yerawada Jail in Pune in the 1930s.[7] The poem was set to music in the 1950s by sitar maestro Ravi Shankar and recorded by singer Lata Mangeshkar.
VINOD SINGH Bhandari on September 21, 2012 It was Mrs Preeti Banedopadhyay, a singer of Indian Peoples' Theatre
Association (IPTA), who first learnt the song from Ravishankar's sitar and
taught the IPTA singers. IPTA accepted it as their Association's theme song
during 1940s.
VINOD SINGH Bhandari on September 21, 2012 Later, other singers started singing this song and Lata Mungeshkar recorded
it. Preeti Bandopadhyay, a nonagenarian, is still alive. Stanzas (1), (3),
(4), and (6) of the song became an unofficial national anthem in India,[1]
VINOD SINGH Bhandari on September 21, 2012 Rakesh Sharma, the first Indian cosmonaut, employed the first line of the
song in 1984 to describe to then prime minister Indira Gandhi how India
appeared from outer space.[9] Current prime minister, Manmohan Singh,
quoted the poem at his first press conference.[1]
akss09 on September 23, 2012 Malik bhai, Jis duniya mein hum rehte hain, usko ladna zyada pasand hai.
Aman se rehne ke liye bahut himmat ki zaroorat hai. Hamari zabaan ek hai,
khana ek hai, mausiki ek hai aur khoon bhi ek hai. Kuch bade logon ne apni
khudgarzi ke liye hamen baant diya aur hum dushman ban pade. Kitne dukh ki
baat hai.
akss09 on September 23, 2012 People are bound to have opinion just like you have yours. There couldn't
be a worse reason than fighting for land, power and religion. We are still
bearing the consequences of the terrible mistake that was committed in
history and God knows how many more years we have to live with it.
Trillions of dollars are spent just on the Indo-Pak border by both the
countries.
akss09 on September 23, 2012 It seems you do not really know the meaning of idol worship. It is a way of
meditating and focusing one's mind on the image of God! What about the
remaining 9 commandments? Are you or your country following it? Do Not
Murder. Do Not LIE. Do Not Steal. Do not commit adultery. Do not covet. Did
God punish your country for all these crimes or is everyone in your country
a saint?
shankyxyz on September 24, 2012 i am not recommending a war with bakistan. all i am saying is that india is
already too unjust a country with too many problems. we dont want a bunch
of roving islamic fanatics added to the long laundry list of our problems.
all the jokers who wanted to do this experiment, got to keep take the
puritans with them. we dont want them back. than you.
Amar Prakash on January 22, 2013 Very good patriotic song indeed
shreyas joshi on November 30, 2013 Long live Asha ji!!
Jagjit Singh Ishar on July 12, 2014 Saw this movie during my school days. Still it's fresh in my soul & mind
with bful melodious songs.
Masterpiece, Hemanthji. Brings tears to my eyes. I don't know exactly why.
May be a combination of the beauty of the song and the lofty ideas
expressed, and thinking about our innocence lost from those times, and the
nation's unfulfilled dreams. Don't really want to allude to the low nadir
reached by the politicians since then - not on this site.