ansari ahemad on May 24, 2013
old is gold

sunetrao on May 28, 2013
Untarnished and shining even now

H Parikh on June 05, 2013
See this is where talat won..'sab kuchh luta ke' sung by both talat and
lata.. talat's pain was natural lata's professilnal..

Durgamaaji on June 09, 2013
Lata ji is simply outstanding; whereas in Talat ji's version his voice
breaks, he stains with the notes and has poor breath control as compared to
the queen of melody Lata ji. We are in deed very fortunate as a nation to
have Lata ji amidst us!

t s parmar on June 13, 2013
super super super in this hot age it is possible,do not upset.

surinder50 on June 30, 2013
It is refreshing to note that at last some else has noted that Lata ji has
exceptionally deep breath...she outsang her co-singers in all duets when it
came to singing several lines in one breath...when others broke breath .

Fahad Imran on July 04, 2013
I will vote for Talat, he wins in putting emotions in the words where Lata
lacks in.

Santosh Srivastava on August 04, 2013
One of my Favorite songs.what are the words,-"Ek bewafa say pyar ka anjaam
to miley."

Madhava Murthy on August 05, 2013
I do not agree with what Durgamaaji has to say about Talatji. The song was
required to be sung in that way only . Talat has done to the song what lata
has done to her version

Shailesh Jha on September 07, 2013
Surinderji, With due respect to The great Lataji..there was a singer called
Mohammad Rafi..who always gave competiton to Lataji. Even Lataji used to
tell her secreatary before a recording with Rafi that "aaj competition
hai". You can listen to songs like "ehsaan tera hoga mujh par, where in
antara..Lataji was not very comfortable with high octave notes...but for
Rafi it was a cakewalk.

Shailesh Jha on September 07, 2013
there are songs like "Rang aur noor ki baraat" "teri aankhon ke siwa" (list
is endless) where most of the people do not know that the same song was
sung by Lataji also..because Rafi version is so popular...i do not agree
with you surinderji...

Shailesh Jha on September 07, 2013
amazing song.

Shailesh Jha on September 07, 2013
I strongly agree with you with due respect to Lataji. Both songs are
greatly sung and you can not compare...

NUSRAT HUQ on October 08, 2013
Madhubala is an eternal beauty!

Niranjan Joshi on November 24, 2013
melodious song of lata

Jagjit Singh Ishar on November 28, 2013
Nice lyrics & the comp[osition. Honey sweet voice of Lata ji.

himanshu9144 on November 30, 2013
colorless relief

kulbeer singh on December 24, 2013
sab kuch luta ke hosh mein honey sweet song goma pk karman jolly

Syed Zaidi on February 27, 2014
Too shrill for my ears. Talat's rendition did justice to the pathos and
emotions in the lyrics. 

Syed Zaidi on February 27, 2014
Too shrill. Talat's did justice to the pathos and emotions in the lyrics.


Nawab IkramUllah Khan on April 06, 2014
Beautiful song

waheed ayub on May 08, 2014
bht khub song hai sb kooch lota k hosh men aye tu kya kia

chand tripuraneni on May 15, 2014
Both versions re great, but I would like to question the people who were
voting for Talat sahibs version to think about how he would sound if he was
to go to the pitch Lataji had to?



Gopal Nair on June 13, 2014
Lata Manna Rafi Mukesh .each is a class by him/herself.

Syed Zaidi on June 16, 2014
At such high pitch Talat Saheb would have also sounded shrill. Some lyrics,
such as in this song, are best expressed in softer, more melancholy style.

On another note, it is easier for the vocal chords to stretch and produce
sustained notes in high octave. It is more challenging to produce
consistent notes in lower octave. That is why all singers, as they grow old
tend to resort to higher notes, thereby compromising the sweetness and
pathos in their voice. LATA, RAFI, MUKESH, KISHORE, SHAMSHAD, NOORJEHAN,
ASHA, and other lesser singers all fell prey to this phenomena. You can
compare their earlier recordings to the ones from their later years and
notice the difference.

This is my humble opinion.



Reincarnation on July 02, 2014
it surely sounds shrill when our female singers of such 'soprano' voice
sing in such high notes; singers of a husky voice will sound very
different. it is up to the m.d. to be cautious about this. talat's is not
only a male but also a 'bass' voice, so there isn't any comparison. but
it's true that very high notes sustained for long in a bareeq voice can
cause discomfort!

JAGDISH GUPTA on August 04, 2014
Beautifully written Lyrics equally beautifully sung by Lata ...Both have
done full justice to their professions..

Dr BrijMohan Bajaj on August 12, 2014
Old is Gold !!!!

Sudheer kumar Sharma on September 04, 2014
A collection of gems.The melody is unparalleled

Azeem Alpha on September 18, 2014
This song’s meaning know only ..Whom failed in love.. ((its my thought )) 

guttenpant on September 30, 2014
DARASAL YAH HAI GAZAL OR tALAT KI AAWAJ MAIN KHOOB JANCHTA HAI

Shakil Khan on October 12, 2014
khubsoorat alfaaz ko badi achi tarah se mausiqi me bandha hai hats off to
ravi saheb

Chandrakant Pusdekar on November 05, 2014
+ONE OF THE BEST !

Murali Iyer on November 07, 2014
Talat,of course, is Talat in his blues mood. And Lata, does her melodious
bit. Bow to Ravi, for this wonderful dual composition!

Renu Takiar on December 22, 2014
It very real

SHANUSHAH on January 02, 2015
Voice of Baby Lata !!!!!

Naresh Bist on January 04, 2015
अच्छा गीत ..नरेश जंग बिस्ट ..निरा बिस्ट निरजा नित्या .निशा निरज जंग बिस्ट
..नेपालगंज..नेपाल

Bharat Lotia on January 21, 2015
Both version is nice hats off taltji & lattaji


Narinder Singh on March 19, 2015
one of my favorite song

TUFAIL HEERA on March 23, 2015
Dear Suhanee !!! It is big honor for me that I am watching this so
beautiful song again. Certainly the is exceptional and unforgettable song
of all times. The song is also holding very charming and very lovely
lyrics. Thank you very much for amazing and RARE upload.

Bhargava Ram on March 31, 2015
Can you find some other singer who could be excelsior than Lataji' singing
quality ? . Never . Talat saheb has sung the same song that would pierce
through the pericardium and get into the heart. Lataji has sung reaching
its highest octave which could not have been possible to Talat saheb.
Bhargavaram 

Love YouTube on April 03, 2015
Old but beautiful song.

wintwonder on April 22, 2015
Thanks Suhani. Just outstanding.

Raman Beri on April 28, 2015
The song was in both male Talat, and female Lata,voices both singers
excelled. Lead pair is Ashok Kumar, Madhubala.Heartiest thanks for
exceptional upload.

Datturao Kulkarni on April 29, 2015
Beautifull song super acting by madhubala Thanks to Suhanee for uploading.

Hasmukh Jhaveri on May 03, 2015
Ek bewafa se pyar ka anjam kya mile.

DIWAKER SHARMA on May 03, 2015
VERY VERY THANKS , PLZ UPLOAD " RAJI HAI HUM USI ME " OLD HINDI SONG

ANWAR7579 on May 20, 2015
Such an awesome and beautiful song.

muhammad niazi on May 21, 2015
No glossy words to praise this song. The lyrics speak for themselves. 

rajinder Sarnamwala on June 01, 2015
Thank you Suhanee2 ji,very nice upload,i knew the version of the man with
Golden voice Talat Mahmoodji. Greetings from south America :)