chrismayka on April 03, 2009
Dear Ramachandra, I can imagine that you were impressed by this song,
thanks for sharing with us, you did a great job, 5***** Our best wishes to
you, Dearest greetings Chris - The Netherlands - Europe - YouTube
chrismayka.

Farrukh Sheikh on April 05, 2009
Nice song of talat and Lata g.Regards

Upendra Lele on June 10, 2009
I have been on the lookout for this song for a long time. Thanks a ton for
posting it. If I am not mistaken the hero is Shammi Kapur?

Upendra Lele on June 10, 2009
Do u have "Dil-e-nadan jamane mein muhabbat ek dhokha hai" by Talat and
Lata? It's such a lovely song!

rumahale on June 19, 2009
Please let me know the name of the movie and other details so as to enable
me search.

rumahale on June 19, 2009
You are right.

khandeel on September 07, 2009
Shakeel badayuni...one of his best lyrics.
thanks for sharing this!

suse1616 on December 04, 2009
beautiful song.thx khurram.u don't happen to arrange one song from ''Gawaiyya'', words are ''teri yaad ka dipak jalata hai, din rat mere veerane mein''.

umerchumerch on December 25, 2009
one of my favourite song.

banff123456 on December 26, 2009
this is my life not a song

nickkohri on March 26, 2010
MD for this song is Ghulam Mohammed.

Pat E on July 19, 2010
Great music by Ghulam Mohd.

rumahale on July 19, 2010
@tymesqr100 Agreed. Thanks.

RealMusicKing on August 23, 2010
A wonderful duet. Both Lata and Talat have done a superb job. Thank you for uploading.

RealMusicKing on August 23, 2010
Hello. That duet is sung by Asha and Talat and is from film "Shah Behram" 1954 I believe. Words are by Asad Bhopali and music by Hanraj Behl.

rumahale on August 23, 2010
@RealMusicKing Thanks for nice comments and appreciation coming from
knowledgeable resource person.

Upendra Lele on August 23, 2010
@RealMusicKing. Hi thanks for the info about Dil-e-nadaan-jamane-mein.
Do you have this video by any chance?

RealMusicKing on August 23, 2010
Rumahaleji. Talat also had two duets in the film with Asha "Baharon ki duniya pukare tu aaja" and "Dekh li aye ishq teri mehrbaani dekh li" that were composed by Sardar Malik, Anu Malik's father.

Also, Ghulam Mohammad helped Shankar Jaikishan with their first film Barsaat and gave them his composition "Main zindagi mein hardam rota hi raha hoon". Same composition was in Laila Majnu sung by Shamshad "Ye jaan ye imaan bas Allah ke liya hai". Listen to the both of them. Regards.

RealMusicKing on August 23, 2010
Your welcome. Sorry I do not. I have it on an LP record "Duets To Remember by Talat Mahmood & Asha Bhosle" that was issued by HMV back in 1984.

rumahale on August 28, 2010
@RealMusicKing I know of "Baharon ki duniya pukare tu aaja" and listened
it. Interesting information to find Ghulam Mohammad helping SJ in Barsaat.
Also interesting to find same tunes in Barsaat and Laila Majnu songs
mentioned above. I have since listened to Shamshad Begum rendition. It is
beautiful. Other one from Mohammad Rafi is very popular and to my liking
since ages. Thanks.

virendra shukla on December 15, 2010
What a beauty in simpleness. thank you

Milahi1935 on April 20, 2011
After listening to Talat, how could any composer give his songs to any
other singer. Lata is excellent, but could be replaced by Asha or Suman
(who is often mistaken for lata), but if you replace talat then the duet
loses it's greatness and may not be the masterpiece that it is now. The
music composers of talat's era were tone deaf and pretty mediocre. They
gave talat only 900 or so songs to sing between 1944 and 1976. They should
have given him at least ten thousand songs. They robbed the Indi

rumahale on September 24, 2011
@Milahi1935 Thanks for liking and beautiful analysis that has enhanced the
quality of presentation besides being a source of encouragement.

rumahale on October 30, 2011
@Milahi1935 Thanks for touching comments.

hrshenoy1 on January 03, 2012
One beautiful song missing from my 2000+ collection. Many thanks. I reached
this song when i was searching for songs based on Bhimpalasi and was
referring to Chandra Courtney's site

rumahale on January 25, 2012
@MrVicshuklanyc Absolutely. Thanks.

Mohd Naseem on February 18, 2012
Never forget to talat and lata, they will alive for ever

Rajesh Kochhar on March 16, 2012
@Milahi1935 You are right. When a song is composed, the composer prepares
it keeping in mind the primary singer. The secondary singer, Lata in this
case, remains secondary. There are many other songs sung by male as well as
female singers. Both are not, cannot be, equally outstanding . ( Example:
Hemant: Sun ja dastan)

Bharath Curam on March 18, 2012
thanks for uploading fantastic song

orawal on March 25, 2012
What a hauntingly beautiful composition!!

rumahale on March 25, 2012
Absolutely. Glad that you liked it. Thanks.

rumahale on May 03, 2012
These old timers had such tremendous effect. Thanks.

Mohd Naseem on May 22, 2012
Like it so much talat and Lata. !!!

rumahale on June 11, 2012
You are right. I like it very much since long - exposure to YouTube has
only enhanced love. Thanks.

rumahale on November 04, 2012
I am overwhelmed to read your vivid description on the song. I too had read
somewhere about the influence of Arabian Music on the senior Music
Directors. I am really interested to know more about it i.e. such of the
MDs and movie songs with influence of Arabian music - this will be precious
information indeed. You may send through personal message leisurely. Thank
you. Ramachandra U Mahale Mysore, India

gopinathan v on January 24, 2013
I started listening to u tube only 5 months ago when I turned 68. I used to
listening to radio ceylon at 16.Though I am from KERALA I like to listen to
hindi melodies of 40'sand 50s.thanks a lot for uploading this gem

rumahale on January 24, 2013
I appreciate your love for old Hindi movie songs; we have Radio Ceylon in
common - it transmits even now with limited duration, added attraction
being it is available online now. Thank you for liking the song and
appreciation.

Vasudeo Shivarekar on March 16, 2013
One of the classic song frm Talat"s Treasure. Thanks for loading

rumahale on August 17, 2013
Thank you for liking.

Harjap Aujla on October 05, 2013
What a great JUGALBANDI between Talat Mahmood and Lata Mangeshkar.

rumahale on October 10, 2013
Thank you for liking and rich appreciation.

Tarsemlal Gercha on October 12, 2013
Sorrow sticken song, heart touching grievances to the almighty"Jal gaya dil
soz-e-gam se jab koi yaad aa gaya" "Aag mein phoolon ke duneya mein mera
tan rakh diya, ek murde ko saja kar naam dulhan rakh diya, Rumahaleji"Who
writes such songs?" Some body asked this question in an old popular
programme of All India Radio. The answer was " No body writes, these are
already written on the heart and come automatically" Thanks for uploading
this gem of great Shakeel, Rumahaleji. Prof. Gercha.

rumahale on October 13, 2013
Well said Sir. Thank you for liking and rich and critical appreciation as
always.

syed naser on October 14, 2013
wah kia jugal bandi kia shayri hay salam

rumahale on October 17, 2013
Thank you for liking and nice comments.

rumahale on October 29, 2013
Thank you for liking and appreciating it.

Bajaury on November 04, 2013
I always wondered who write such lyrics. You answered it beautifully,
"These are written on the heart and just pours out.". Great quote. Thanks
for sharing your insight.

rumahale on November 05, 2013
After seeing the excellent comment from the learned viewer "Bajary" I have
viewed your comment again; well said of the lyrics - true; "nobody writes,
but, these are already written in the heart and come automatically".Thanks
again.

Tarsemlal Gercha on November 05, 2013
Thanks a lot Bajauryji and Rumahaleji for liking my comments on the song
"Aasma wale teri duniya se jee ghabra gaya chaar din ke chaanne mein gam ka
badal chaa gaya". from the film Laila Majnu. I appreciate your response.
Thanks again. Prof. Gercha.

Lalji Ashar on December 22, 2013
Bollywood's sweet old song