V. Siddhartha on August 28, 2010
The pictures are meticulously aligned with the words of the geet made
timeless by Khursheed Bano. A later version by Nayyara Noor is also very
melodious, but the KB rendition stands in a class by itself. You gave a
nice secular interpretation of the love theme focused on Madhubala and DK,
but the verse is originally both secular and spiritual in its message; it
easily lends itself to a double-layered meaning .Thanks, myvision22.

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on August 28, 2010
The torment one has to suffer in love has been beautifully recaptured by
you and symbolized with new icons, MB and DK. It was a sad chapter of the
life of the greatest beauty queen of Indian films, who lost her heart in
this deal. You have befittingly selected this song to narrates the true
story of their love. Great work. Thanks Mukhtar Sahab.

syed2247 on August 28, 2010
Great upload. Thanks

kuckudk on August 29, 2010
Wah Wah Mukhtar Bhai, you have studded Diamonds into this Old Gold. I
salute your Imagination and Hard work, you have incorporated very suitable
clips according to the words of the song. By the way how many days you
worked on this project.

Shiv Shanker on August 29, 2010
Excellent video ... very very melodious and meaningful song... sang in
avery sweet voice by Khurshid Begum... thanks for sharing... keep up the
good work Mukhtar bhai...

SeaBreezeCenter on August 29, 2010
An excellent upload. Thanks for sharing.

kuckudk on August 29, 2010
@kuckudk Your selection of Madhbala and Dilip Kumar is very thoughtful and
appropriate. MB loved DK but could not get him and died yearning for a true
lover.

salil dixit on August 29, 2010
mukhtar bhai, very very nice . many thanks for sharing this beautiful work .

jaiminimunshi on August 29, 2010
Wow what a collection. Mukhtarbhai , I reaaly appreciate your efforts for caring of such a beauttiful and rare songs.

vintagemelodies on August 29, 2010
The words blends in perfect sync with the visuals. Excellent !

jasbongy on August 29, 2010
Very beautiful song with touching,soulfil lyrics. Khurshid Begum sings
brilliantlly and touches the heart. I have heard this song first time by
Nayyra Noor ji on ''cheecheepia '' channel by Khalid VBhai.and that moment
i became fan of Nayyra ji. Then heard in melodious voice of D.K. Sharma ji
''kuckudk.'' And now presented briliantlly by myvision ji. I am very happy
to see this is dedicated to Chandrashekharjain ji. Thanks myvision ji and
Shekhar Bhaiya for sharing. With respect. Sarla.

Jagjit Singh Ishar on August 29, 2010
mukhtar sahib i m over joyed 2 c ur nu rendition as a tribute 2 khurshid
bano superimposed on madhubala & dalip kumar. the montage with lip
coincidence is a hard task but u hv managed well & deserve appreciation 4
ur enticing imagination. if u remember i had once requested u 4 this song &
u hv obliged. plz accept my best wishes. wud b over joyed 4 ur next project
on ghata ghanghor ghor mor machaye shor i think frm movie taansen. thanx &
god bless u.

Dee Thakore on August 29, 2010
@kuckudk thanks for this gem.

Amjad Zia Mughal on August 29, 2010
Hi ,,, its U mukhtar sahb .(..immortal song ) wah wah very good job thnx
for sharing regrads amjad

buddha2ndcumming on August 31, 2010
Sir,I am so happy that the labor of your love finally came out.Being one of the priviliged few who watched this video during its making one fine evening at your place,i dont have enough words to appreciate the intensity of your passion for this song.simply beautiful and sublime...transcends us to another world..keep up the great work you are doing in inspiring novices like us to great and beautiful gems..we wouldnt have found such treasures if it were not for your passion for such music..

musafir39 on September 01, 2010
Luxury video compilance. Happy confluence of the lyrics, music and voice.
Thank you for sharing your unique creation.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on September 05, 2010
@buddha2ndcumming, Nothing can explain the humble feeling I have for all
the people who have made this possible. Mukhtar

nrkamath43211 on September 06, 2010
Dear Mukhtar Bhai, Thanks you so much for sharing this GEM of a song. This
is one of my most favorite songs based on Raga Kedar. This song comes very
meldious on my Flute. Excellent appropriate videography. Wonderful! Wah Wah
Kya Baat Hai. Aap Ne To Maar Daala. CHEERS, Dr. Kamath

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on September 06, 2010
@nrkamath43211 Dear Dr. Kamath I am highly thankful for your generous and
kind comments. It made my efforts worthwhile. It takes a pure soul to be
able to fully appreciate the anguish, agony and ecstasy of love and human
relationships expressed in this gem by DN Madhok. Thanks a lot again.
Mukhtar

saz9297 on September 07, 2010
I've already given my appreciating comment on PANCHI BAWARA (bhagat surdas)
excellent indeed. besides you have also uploaded a very rare song AIK NAZAR
by surrendar kaur (film Naao). this very beautiful song i heard first time.
clips you attached with this song is of course fantastic and very
bewitching. your effort is no doubt highly admirable. hope to have more
such rare songs to listen. thank you regards

chandrashekharjain on September 11, 2010
Thank you Mukhtar bhai for creating this difficult video,upon my persistent
request and dedicating it especially to my father Narinder Sain, who was a
great fan of Khursheed. I have been watching the comments by so many
viewers constantly, and I am delighted to that this video has been well
received by all the viewers. It is all due to the imaginative craftsmanship
of Mukhtar ji. . My father stayed in Digamber Jain hostel while at Govt
College Lahore early 40s. Does this hostel still exists?

chandrashekharjain on September 11, 2010
@imadbhai1234 Excuse me sir, name of the singer is Khursheed Begum, or
Khurshid begum/ Kuurshid Bano and also known as Irshad Begum. I have never
heard she been called as Tani Khursheed ! Perhaps she was named 'Tani' in
film Tansen This song is from film Bhagat Soor Dass, though spelled
differently at different places. Songs by her in film Tansen were also
good. Please do correct me if I am wrong. Pl. see the video link given
below. More bachpan ke saathi ( Tansen 1942)

60arvind on September 19, 2010
well no words except thanks.

chotasagar on October 28, 2010
Mukthar Bhai, Thank you for sharing this old gem of a song by Khurshid
Begum Ji. I cannot recall listening to the song previously or if I have not
knowing who who sang it? You hard endeavours, dedication has certainly
realised in fruition in your own imaginative video creativity presentation.
A very enjoyable moment and again thanks for sharing. Best Regards...Siraj

Balbir Sood on February 09, 2011
An evergreen rendering by Khurshid Begum!!!

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on February 09, 2011
@Roparwala thanks a lot for liking my presentation.

Milahi1935 on May 31, 2011
Khursheed has sung better than perfectly. Her voice has a seductive quality
unlike any other. She had great range and showed her high notes whenever
the mediocre music composers would compose songs with high notes. Noor
jehan praised khursheed a lot for her ability to sing all kinds of songs.

angandhe on October 18, 2011
Which is film of vedeo

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on October 27, 2011
@angandhe It is Tarana Mukhtar

Milahi1935 on March 22, 2012
I have heard this song a thousand times and every time it sounds better.
What a gift for music lovers.

KIRANJIT SANDHU on May 06, 2012
This Song by Khursheed is from Film " Bhakat Surdas" . This film has songs
of KC Dey (Uncle of Manna Dey) also . I have LP of KC Dey released by HMV
which was 1st published in 1960s.

Dilip Gupte on July 05, 2012
One of very fine sons. However, the video is of the film of much later
years.

Fawad Kashif on September 10, 2012
great job mukhtar sahab. i really appreciate your creativity sensitivity
observation and deep editing sense. awesome work.

shamshudin premji on October 07, 2012
You are doing a great work for all those who appreciate old but a real
jewel of Indian film industry as some one said "old is gold" those were the
days, every song touched your heart in one way or the other. Keep up the
good work. thanks.

SHENOY BV on October 22, 2012
Mukhtar Sheikh Saab, this song has been my father's favourite, which he
used to hum at night in the early fifties and ever since, it has remained
my perennial favourite. Thanks for uploading the song as also then
beautiful video.

Karamjeet Singh on December 16, 2012
The song is really melodious.Chaukar also keeps looking at the moon and
longs for it(have a strong wish).May be Panchi Bawra is used in generic
form.Sikh Hymn also metaphors the soul to crave for God like
Chaukaur.Thanks Sumant ji for forwarding this song.Kjs

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on December 17, 2012
Dear Karam Jeet ji, I am highly thankful for your nice comments. It takes a
pure soul to be able to fully appreciate the anguish, agony and ecstasy of
love and human relationships expressed in this gem by DN Madhok. The poetry
can be related to God also. It depends upon the listener. Best regards
Mukhtar

RAJMOHAN CHAUHAN on December 18, 2012
My father always hummed this song when I was just 5-6 year old. I never
imagined I would see this song with my own eyes some day. Thanks for
posting it. It is like finding my childhood days of innocence. Please let
me know what Raag is it?

robaspiring on February 04, 2013
Yes nostalgic. Thanks honestly no sweetness compared to Lata rather too
nasal avoice.

Bash Ali on June 14, 2013
Dear Mukhtar Sahib - I am impressed by your hard work in translating
"Panchi Bawra . . ." It is an ample proof of your love and dedication of
old gem music. The reality is that life is too short but the art is long.
It is my desire to establish a contact with you. I have written an email to
your email address that I found - mukhtarsheikh@hotmail.com and I sure hope
you get it and that I do hear from you. With my best regards, Basharat -
ilahsab@gmail.com

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on June 15, 2013
Dear Basharat sahib, I really feel elevated when a person like you
appreciates my work with such nice words. Your admiration of my creation
makes me so proud. It gives confidence to me to do even better. I am
grateful for your email address and I will love to contact you. Thanks and
best regards Mukhtar

Bash Ali on June 19, 2013
Dear Mukhtar Sahib - The email I sent you on your Hotmail address did not
get delivered. Would you please write me on my address or provide me your
email address that would work. Thanks. Basharat

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on June 20, 2013
Dear Basharat sahib, Please find my email address. I have been waiting for
it. mukhtarasheikh@hotmail.com mukhtarasheikh@gmail.com

Ji Pran on August 10, 2013
I level this song as Sufi song, I may be wrong.

Shaukat Jamil on August 23, 2013
Who is the MD?

Tarsem Lal Gercha on August 24, 2013
Thanks for the genuine and nice traslation of the lyrics True, each word of
the lyrics has very deep meanings. In poetry the love of Chanda and Chakore
is well known particularly it is at the top on the full moon day.I.e
why"Jyun jyun preet badaye ga tu, tyun tyun woh gatt jaye..."Ilove this
song too much since my childhood and have HMV record with me. Thanks for
uploading this gem . Prof. Gercha

penta15786 on September 08, 2013
Dear Mukhtar Sahib, This song brings back the memory of my late father who
owned a record store and whenever possible used to encourage us to listen
to classics. Now he is gone and I am missing him more than words can
express. To me these songs are a connection to those times when life was
simpler, people were loving, respect for teachers and elders were the norm
and passionate love for God and all his creation was the order of the day.
Yes we have money but nobody to share with.

jaswinder ahluwalia on October 23, 2013
KL Saigal also sang this song. I regard both singers masters par excellence
of their art Maybe some fans may differ and prefer one to the other

Jayanthi Nadig on April 27, 2014
Awesome song by Khursheed ji, It is a very captivating tune in Raag
"Kedar". I have gone crazy listening to this over and over. Thanks a
million for this upload/share :). Appreciate it.

akarshik on April 27, 2014
What a amazing singing by Khursheed, it touches right to the Heart.