V. Siddhartha on June 04, 2009
"Mubarak ghair ko khushiyan, mujhe gham se muhabbat hai... na milta gham to
barbadi ke afsane kahan jate... agar duniyan chaman hoti to virane kahan
jate." This sad song is not just a lament on a cruel fate ; it's Sufi
poetry at its most profound. Lataji's voice and Nimmi's acting both seem to
come from deep within their hearts. Can they leave any listener unmoved to
tears? A splendid post from a great film filled with moving lyrics and
soul-stirring melodies. Thanks, Suhanee.

Zafar Ahsan on June 04, 2009
The romance of b/w lives, this song is Amar, as the the film is, like its
name. Nimmi, if I am right in her prime, the master piece close ups, the
back ground composition, even the slow blowing wind seems to match up so
perfectly with the sitar chords and the mode of the song. hai sab se madhur
woh geet jinhein hum dard ke sur mein gate hein. To balance all this
blacks, Dilip is providing his dazzling whites, which in fact don't relate
to his role in this movie.The inner conflict (cond)

Zafar Ahsan on June 04, 2009
is again picturized in the song "insaf ka mandir hai bhagwan ka hgar hai"of
the same movie. Many thanks to suhanee.

V. Siddhartha on June 04, 2009
..Another heartrending line in this exquisite Shakeel Badayuni poem is:
Chalo achha hua apno mein koyi ghair to nikla , agar hote sabhi apne to
begane kahan jate.Such acceptance of human vulnerability, such resignation
to fate, accompanied by forgiveness extended to one's own tormentors, only
comes from a deep grasp of how all dualities, all good and bad, are
inextricably intertwined in our lives.

jasbongy on June 04, 2009
So true.r the lyrics of this song.Lata ji's very beautifull emotional song
on Nimmi ji.who expressed so well ''Dard'' by Her acting
prowess.5*****thanks Suhanee ji for uploading this gem.

Ramesh Rawat on June 04, 2009
...and the similar expressions in yet another... jo bijli chamakti hai unke
mahal par, wo kar le tasalli mera ghar jala kar.salamat rahe tu meri
jaan jaaye..

crazyoldsongs on September 11, 2009
what a beautiful sad song. always loved it and even have an audio cassette
of amar and andaaz. although i havent seen the movies . .just came across
this and i am in tears. thanks for your kindness. this is a pleasant
surprise and i like yr idea of written lyrics.

rumahale on September 11, 2009
Thanks for the liking and keen interest evinced. I believe the lyrics
supplement the video.

V. Siddhartha on September 13, 2009
Notice the extraordinary range of emotions that Nimmi beautifully expressed
in three songs, the deeply touching feelings of suffering, injustice,
abandonment and grief in this song and Khamosh Hai Khewat and joy in Ek
Baat Kahoon. Of course, Lata and Asha were there to help her out on the
musical level. Thanks for all the Amar posts, Ramchandraji.

rumahale on September 13, 2009
Thanks for the rich comments. The emotions have great impact. I have not
seen the movie, but now referred to the details regarding its plot; and,
was moved very much. All in all the movie is superb thanks to all those who
contributed for its success including Mehboob Khan - Producer. Regards.

jeetendra5 on September 30, 2009
Never seen this before!!! Very sad and emotional song but I love.

Fresh oldie and Lata mangeshkar voice is so touchy.

thanks

rumahale on September 30, 2009
Thanks for liking and comments. Amar movie had beautiful songs.

HIMCHOLI RAY on December 26, 2012
Superb wording,excellent acting,amazing Lataji as alwais thnks a lot for
uploading it,may God bless you and help you in all your endeavers.,

rumahale on December 27, 2012
Thank you for liking, appreciation and kind words. It is one of my most
favourite songs.

Indu Puri on August 02, 2013
na milataa gam to barabaadi ke afasaane kahaan jaate agar duniyaa chaman
hoti, to viraane kahaan jaate chalo achchhaa huaa apano me koi gair to
nikalaa ji, koi gair to nikalaa agar hote sabhi apane, to begaane kahaan
jaate..waaaah ! kitna bda sch! kitna drd!

rumahale on August 03, 2013
Thank you for liking and touching comments as always.

rumahale on September 04, 2013
Thank you for liking and nice comments.

javed shah khajrana on September 04, 2013
Nimmi Ki Aankhon Me Jo Kashish Hai Lagta hai Wo Aankhon Se Hi Apne Jazbaat
Bayan kar Dengi ..

rumahale on September 04, 2013
Well said. Thank you for liking and nice comments.

rumahale on September 07, 2013
Thank you for liking and nice comments.

Ashok Kumar Sethi on October 23, 2014
चलो अच्छा हुआ,अपनों में कोई गैर तो निकला
अगर होते सभी अपने,तो बेगाने कहां जाते.

The lyrics of the songs are unforgetable . The song is soul searching and
heart rendering voice catches your attention. Never to forget songs.Gone
are the lyricists and musics directors who created this real world of human
emotions. 

Hasmukh Jhaveri on March 06, 2015
best lyrics and best music by naushaad ali.

Ashok Kumar Sethi on April 21, 2015
Chalo achchha hua apnon mein koi gair to nikala, agar hotey sabhi apane to
begane kahan jaate. very melodious an emotional song from Film "Amar".
This is unforgetable song and shall remain ringing in the mind and heart of
people till this world comes to an end.

K C Gupta on July 17, 2015
tumhi ne gham ki daulat di bada ehsaan farmaaya, jamane bhar ke aage haath
failane kahan jaate ? kitana dard hai is nagme main.

Assad Zaheer on November 27, 2015
urdu is very sweet language.