pankajnarula84 on December 13, 2012
sorry mob, my opinion is different. just ruined the original track, i don't
like even a single line. my first dislike on you tube.

Mohit Bagdwal on December 21, 2012
Evr try 2 sing in a high note! Dn u'll realize can u really sing bttr dan
him?

dalmadiwana on December 22, 2012
Sorry, but you just screwed up the lyrics. I couldn't go beyond the mukhda.

dalmadiwana on December 22, 2012
Dude , take it easy . What I said is the fact - what you are saying is your
interpretation. Check out lyrics of the original song and you will
appreciate what I said. O re piya ... haayaa not he .. why did he have to
screw it that way ? Sounded awful to me.

dalmadiwana on December 22, 2012
Dude , take it easy . What I said is the fact - what you are saying is your
interpretation. Check out lyrics of the original song and you will
appreciate what I said. O re piya ... haayaa not he .. why did he have to
screw it that way ? Sounded awful to me.

geeta on December 23, 2012
musicians are so... yum...

sankha mukherjee on December 26, 2012
ja'far parakkat@ One more like from me..

silversurfur dorion gry on December 26, 2012
HAHAHAHAHAH no son ,.,. not at all .,. close ur eyes son and drift ,.
lolllll

silversurfur dorion gry on December 26, 2012
well son ., just shoz what u no son lollll

Sankalp Sarnobat on January 07, 2013
just gr8.. especially "o re piya" part of it :)

sanamo86 on January 12, 2013
if it is his 1st attempt at singing O re Piya, why did he make the effort
of singing in a recording studio, use a HD video cam & not actually
rehearse the song, so that the vocals & pronouciations are correct. Rahat's
O re Piya might have taken several takes, Iv'e heared him singing 1 meter
from me & he sounded bloodly brilliant, note & pronounciation perfect. My
point is the singer is not bad, its just he hasnt got the ability to sing
indian classical, so he shouldnt have attempted this song

scahuja on January 12, 2013
Compared to the original, pronunciation was slightly off, but overall, very
impressed. This is NOT an easy song to sing. Agreed that original artists
are always going to be hard to beat, but the mixture of east meets west is
amazing. In evaluating through watching multiple videos here, I will also
point out that Shankar is also an amazing artist. I don't know about you
guys, but I'm a subscriber! :-) Keep up the great work

kkrdgulzar on January 12, 2013
All Those who are commenting on his Pronunciation- Save your comments. In
music there is no right, wrong, correct, incorrect, for pronunciation.
Listen to some of the greatest songs & notice they were not pronounced in
'correct' way. What is correct to you, is not necessarily correct, it is
just that you are 'used to it'. The word 'Shruti' in a lot of north Indian
languages is 'Sruti' - Wrong? not at all. - Enjoy the Shruti - if you know
what it means & you will not worry about pronunciation.

piyush bhandari on January 12, 2013
Even d Indoclassic part had a bit influence of western classically trained
voice. Nice song overall . I have never seen someone singing Indian
classical and Western classic in one go and justifying both at the same
time apart from sonu nigam is a diffrent case.

Rakesh Nandi on January 13, 2013
Some changes are acceptable but completely changing the language is
something very awkward. I am not commenting on his Singing, he is a
fantastic singer but his pronunciation is really very wrong. Just an
example, he is pronouncing "haye" as "hai", which is changing the meaning
of the sentence completely. little changes can be done unless that
doesn't affect the lyrics. Hope u understand. :)

Rihab Khan on January 14, 2013
Ur awesome tucker!

sanamo86 on January 15, 2013
I sgree with your point about singers having ranges, but please explain to
me If your a singer who hasnt got the ability to sing Indian classical and
its out of your vocal range, why attempt to sing it & most of all upload an
HD video of it. You are bound to attract crticism. Also pronunciation has
nothing to do with vocal range and that is something he messed up completely

Mandeep Ranu on January 16, 2013
a r rahman ka beta!!!

sanamo86 on January 16, 2013
ermmm more like you lost the argument & havent got the guts to admit it. No
thank you, I dont wanne be friends with you mate

fahmeda118 on January 17, 2013
super like this, the rock element towards the end is brilliantly done

pradeeps1987 on January 19, 2013
GHANTA pronunciation ! SunNa hai to suno warna doosra koi gaana sunke so
jao !

Rakesh Nandi on January 19, 2013
Then for you I can just say ""WOW"".. Hello Mr. Oversmart... first learn
hindi then comment!!! :)

Nishit Rai on January 20, 2013
Jst owsum...

Zeeshan N on January 22, 2013
what the heck was that ?? terrible idea

Zeeshan N on January 22, 2013
No where close to Rahat Fateh Ali Khan and Adele !! That was one epic fail
!! Nice Try though :)

prabhu murthy on January 23, 2013
if u dont like , Then you are welcome to GTFOH

onetwo27 on January 23, 2013
Holy god please dont bring the language politics into music too . Its
music and it dosent need any language -_-

Govind Pillai on January 27, 2013
y cant u ppl juz enjoy da musiq!!!

Aisik Sur on January 30, 2013
"sakal pe mat jao.. apni akal lagao".could't able to believe tis chap
has got such powerful english pronunciation...

roz fille on January 30, 2013
WE WANT MORE !!

81sush on February 01, 2013
you have got a beautiful voice.. and the english rendition is awesome...
loved both parts

Joshua Joseph on February 02, 2013
Don't ever insult the original like that. This is a great adaptation from
only one of the best songs Bollywood has ever released.

Shivani Patel on February 04, 2013
This is just too amazing! God blessed you with an amazing voice!

Varadraj Adya on February 07, 2013
Awesome Composition...Managed very well by the singer...Treat for ears...

Aanchal Kaushal on February 08, 2013
Blind Man!! calling it good & saying people to appreciate is negative for
u.. haha .. dare to talk to those who says "GHANTA" or calls it an insult
to the real.. I've actually appreciated the singer bcoz I liked his voice..
Talk to a man like this he'll reply u better & in a great tongue !

Manisha B on February 10, 2013
Great sound on the clarinet! Plus I think he sang Rolling in the Deep
better. O re piya in the beginning was not good. But nice job

IBRAHIM ali on February 11, 2013
Mashallah ..Mast hai

Sharat Subramanian on February 14, 2013
In my opinion, the best by shankar tucker..!! amazing..! :)

Rahul Upadhyaya on February 17, 2013
good stuff ... neatly executed too.. love it :D

paragf17 on February 17, 2013
I lyk it...frnd...

Young Old on February 19, 2013
take a chill pill...

Sahil Sharma on February 19, 2013
1:38 to 1:44 best part ... good job buddy!

priyesh sanghvi on February 22, 2013
very nyc...loved the sound of clarinet ...

Marsbars Kidrauhl on February 23, 2013
woah talk bout not being a freshy

jimmy jims on February 24, 2013
you outta ur mind??? NO ONE CAN EVER SING THIS LIKE RAHAT FATEH ALI KHAN
DID, WHAT U KNOW ABOUT MUSIC??

wastoidjunkie on February 25, 2013
Big Up for the massive tabla arrangement!

JINERPIL on February 27, 2013
Hats off shanker tucker.. u should have been indian and be contributing to
indian film .

Pallavi Sawant on February 28, 2013
Shankar!! Shankar!! Shankar!!!!____/\____

Shubhro Sinha on March 02, 2013
Lovely! Awesome!

Himavanth Yennu on March 02, 2013
awesome...:)