krhapa pukhtunkhwa on June 27, 2010
your upload is professional quality.thank you for sending it to me.deir
amad drust amad.

SeaBreezeCenter on June 27, 2010
Thank you very much for uploading this melodious song of Jagmohan Ji. A
great voice indeed. I enjoyed it very much.

kuckudk on June 27, 2010
Dear Mr Mukhtar You have done a great service to the music lovers by
uploading this old gem. Your labour to create this beautiful video is
hundred percent success. It is fantastic.You have transformed this 70 years
old song into a 21st century classic. Please throw some light on Kamal Das
Gupta also. The information about Jagmohan provided by you proves your
passion for the Music and the old legendary singers. Keep it up. This goes
to my favourite list.

Shiv Shanker on June 27, 2010
unbelievable... so melodious... very good ... thanks to D.K.Sharma ji who
sent it me for listening... this is really a gem... Shiv Shanker

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on June 27, 2010
@kuckudk Thanks a lot for encouraging comments. I will put more information
on Kamal Dasgupta on my other creation "Aye Chand Shup na jana". Mukhtar

jasbongy on June 27, 2010
@myvision22 Wow not only for song and melodious singing of Jagmohan ji but
for beautiful videography with Poonam and Sushmita Sen.Thumbs Up. I rally
like this awesome singer's 1. Dil ko Tumse Pyar kayon ? and 2.Muje na sapno
se bahelao. In 60 's his songs were often heard on Radio. Thanks myvision22
ji and Sharma ji for sharing. W.R. Sarla.

jasbongy on June 27, 2010
@myvision22 Thanks Sharma ji for sharing this awesome song. With respect.
Sarla.

salil dixit on June 27, 2010
mukhtar bhai, this is awesome. i am very grateful to you for sharing this
with me .

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on June 27, 2010
"Beautiful!----------- Pure art work.-------- Loved it.-----How could you
do it, Mukhtar ji, please tell me, please, pleeeeeeesease. Thanks".

V. Siddhartha on June 27, 2010
@kuckudk . Thanks, Sharmaji, for the forward. In the 1940s, KLS, Jagmohan,
and Pankaj Mullick were the male troika that reigned supreme on the radio.
I am a pushover for Jagmohan. His soothing voice can easily be used as a
pain-relieving drug. This song is clearly an adaptation of Meghduta( "
Cloud Messenger"), the great Sanskrit poem of Kalidasa, the Shakespeare of
ancient Gupta Dynasty. The presentation by myvision22 is a fitting visual
rhapsody and a labor of love. Wonderful!

V. Siddhartha on June 27, 2010
@myvision22 .Kamal Dasgupta was a noted composer and a lyricist and singer
too. He was married to the Bengali singer Firoza Begum. He gave many tunes
to Jagmohan, Juthika Roy, and Kanan Devi.

kalakar67 on June 28, 2010
Beautiful presentation.!! GREAT WORK...!!

IMIRZA777 on June 28, 2010
Rare gem... Thanks for sharing.

tmjatala on June 28, 2010
Jagmohan ne kabhi khwab bhi na dekha ho ga geet wo aaj ga raha hai 70 saal
guzarne k baad Lyallpur ka aik funkar os geet ko itnay khoobsurat andaz
mein pesh kare ga . Yeh peshkush irti umda hai aur iss mein itni znazaktein
hein jin ki wazahat k liye aik mazmoon darkar hai, Iss pumbhal poosay main
ulajhne ki bajaye behter hai k I may watch it once more .

chandrashekharjain on June 28, 2010
watching the visual clipping with musical input is a real treat to soul and
very soothing to mind. It is very imaginative, innovative and excellent
with reference to expressing the moods matching to the wordings, tunes and
musics and of course the various shades of two original colors black and
white.

chandrashekharjain on June 28, 2010
It is very engrossing putting any one in the state similar to meditations
leading towards tranquility and divinity together. It may be able to
attract back the hi-tech generation towards the rich ethnic tradition.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on June 28, 2010
@chamogaa Thank you for comments on my video. It is your comments which
inspired me to change title of my video from "A Journey of clouds" to "A
message through clouds. Mukhtar

Jagjit Singh Ishar on June 29, 2010
ur montage & efforts r highly fabulous in bringing forward the gr8 legends
to the fore & let the world see how gr8 were those people who created so
butiful gems. mukhtar g its awesome & plz keep it up. thanx.

Suhanee2 on June 29, 2010
@chandrashekharjain Thanks for sharing this beautiful video with me, it
reminds me of the days when my father so fondly would listen to Jagmohan ji
, this song brings back beautiful memories of the past, this number is a
are gem, it's precious and the video is beautiful, very creative, I simply
loved it. Thanks to Mukhtar Sahab for uploading this video and my Heartiest
Congratulation on your beautiful Channel. Best regards, Suhanee!!

crazyoldsongs on June 29, 2010
@chamogaa thanks vipan da for sharing this amazing song . i think i am
hearing it for the first time and not familiar with the name jagmohan , i
have heard a few songs of this era and am familiar with some songs of
sehgal ,pankaj mullick and ch atma as my father used to love them . this is
just a magnificent composition and i loved hearing it . now that i see in
related videos , i am familiar with the song ''dil ko hai tumse pyaar kyun
'' which i did not know ,was sung by jagmohan.

crazyoldsongs on June 29, 2010
@crazyoldsongs this is indeed a precious upload and an aural and visual
delight . the presentation is absolutely beautiful and compliments the
singing and the music . thanks for introducing me to this song and this
wonderful singer . thanks myvision22 for posting this gem with so much
creativity .

kusumsharmaajmer on June 29, 2010
Sharma ji, bahut bahut dhanyawad. Really rare and beautiful upload by
Mukhtaar Saheb.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on June 30, 2010
@123sheikh Thanks

shafiqgulam shaikh on July 16, 2010
A very rare gem!! Thanks!!

Tejpal Oberoi on July 16, 2010
The classic "Meghdootam" is recreated in Jagmohan's immortal voice by
kamaldas gupta and very tenderly presented through excellent video
compiliation by Mukhtarji. I think a video creator of this calibre shud be
a good film director, very appropriate selection of video montage capturing
the mood of the song. Hearty congratulations Mukhtarji.

Eswar Nakka on July 17, 2010
Muktar Bhai Jiyo hazar saal, yeh mera aaseerwad (blessings) ka sandes hai.
As detailed by Tenioberoi , Kavi Kalidas has written a great Kavyam called
MEGHADUTHAM in Sanskrit, also known as MEGHASANDESAM. Kamal Das Guptha was
a great composer. Thanks and blessings Uma Maheswar Nakka

arvindpradhan on July 22, 2010
Mukhtar bhai, This song is a classic film interpretation of the great
Indian poet Kalidas (4 th century) written great epic called Meghdoot.
Kalidas was the first poet in the subcontinent to conceive of the idea of a
cloud carrying a message. Great song. Bahot shukriya.

Ajay Yuvraj on July 23, 2010
Great work Mukhtar bhai, Beautifully done.

chandrashekharjain on July 23, 2010
Capt Kundaliya comments; Excellent performance !! Keep it up. From deep
past to present.

vintagemelodies on July 25, 2010
Dear Sir, Thanks for this excellent combination of visuals commensurate
with the moods of the song by Jagmohan 'Sur Sagar'. The theme is similar to
that of Kalidasa's Epic Poem 'Meghadootam' wherein the a 'yaksha', the
demi-gods in indian mythology sends the cloud as his messenger to convey
his thoughts to his beloved wife far away. with regards

passion689 on July 26, 2010
This is one of the most exraordinary presentations I have come across. Touching lyrics are sequenced with equally touching and befitting background scenes, particularly the lightening storm and swiftly moving restless clouds, depicting the heart in extreme turmoil. Thank you Mukhtar ji for sharing it with me, I enjoyed watching it. Take care.

Frans Bhawanidin on August 14, 2010
Nice : old is gold.

Frans Bhawanidin on August 14, 2010
Nice : old is gold.

rumahale on August 15, 2010
It is a great presentation and to my liking. Thanks for sharing.

nrkamath43211 on September 06, 2010
Dear Mukhtar Bhai, This is a GEM which I am thankful to you for uploading
and letting me know. I heard this song after decades. I love voice of
Jagmohan Sursingar Ji that is what he was called. You description and video
assembly is simply marvellous. I always LOVE to sing Jagmaohan's song "Dil
Ko Hai Tumse Pyaar Hai Kyon". Someday, I will upload my version. Regards,
Dr. Kamath

rajivsood25 on October 01, 2010
I salute on your selection and choices of your songs. You are really an
artist. Your presentation is unique. By presenting this way , you added
additional value in the song.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on October 02, 2010
@rajivsood25 Thank you for the nice comments

AghaZulqarnainPasha on October 08, 2010
This is rare song. Thanks for sharing with folk

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on October 08, 2010
@AghaZulqarnainPasha Thanks a lot Agha sahib for your comments.

madhubala2009 on November 22, 2010
Thank you so much Mukhtar ji,this is another song that I wanted to upload in Facebook but I forgot my own name there:)
This clip,like all your masterpieces, is a stunning visual poem,so illustrative that this timeless song will be understood and appreciated by people all over the world.I need to see all of your super editions and improvements of the originals.
This is not flattery ,what could I win with it?Just an opinion(of a fan:)

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on November 22, 2010
@madhubala2009 Dear Kiri san Thanks for your very inspiring and generous
comments, appreciating my efforts to create a video on this marvelous and
eternal song. Such nice comments provide me the strength to compile videos
with confidence. Mukhtar

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on February 03, 2011
@Pashambay Dear Balouch Sahib, Thanks for writing knowledgeable comments on
our favourite song. I am proud of my creation on this great song. Actually,
when I was middle school student, I would listen radio Ceylon for hours in
search of two songs 1. O varsha ke pehle badal.. from geets and 2. Kaise
koi jiye .from old song. In the course of waiting for these songs, I would
listen and started liking many other songs too. Please email the song at
mukhtarasheikh@hotmail.com Thanks Mukhtar

bazlur on February 25, 2011
You suggested to listen his song, but when I heard his voice and I was
thinking it is like Jagonmoy Mitra, but I did not know that in Hindi his
name is Jagmohon. He is my very favorite singer in Bengali, specially his
songs called Chiti, 15. Ami Duranta Baishakhi Jhar and others. Did you read
his interview with Quereshi?

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on February 25, 2011
@bazlur Yes, his original name is Jagonmoy Mitra. In Hindi songs, he is
called Jagmohan or sursagar. I feel, he is more renown in Bengal.

Narayan Madhav Damle on July 10, 2011
I am very very thankful for this song. Is this what Kalidas tells the first
rainy clouds in"Meghdoot'

vinay k joshi on September 06, 2011
I first heard his songs in Vivdh Bharti in1967 at 10-11 AM programs, when
his songs were a regular feature.

saz9297 on October 19, 2011
Mukhtar saheb. this geet is one of my most favourite and i often listen
from my collection. admirable is he sings this song in different mode and
pitch. thank you

saz9297 on October 19, 2011
@saz9297 oho i forgot to watch beautiful vdo attachment that fits exactly
to this geet. in fact i became engrossed. anyhow i enjoyed well watching
this enchanting vdo and listening this geet again. you deserve to be highly
appreciated. marvelous indeed thank you mukhtar saheb

namudia1 on November 19, 2011
Remind meghdoot by Kalidasa?

arvind ketkar on November 20, 2011
Dear mukhtar bhai salaam walekum,THANKU FOR A BEAUTIFUL SONG ,GOD BLESS U
AAPNE TO HAME MADHOSH KAR DIYA BHAI K ARVIND