Shannon Donald Official on June 09, 2011
amazing her voice is super controlled. Way to go Harshdeep!

Shannon Donald Official on June 09, 2011
Wow it really picks up in the middle. Forgot how good this song was!

indirockfella92 on June 09, 2011
@zakirhusainsuthar yeah yeah,u r the best and we r the worst...blah blah
blah...pahunch gayi dil ko thandak? Now shut up,sit back and enjoy the
song!

Paritosh Sharma on June 10, 2011
great effort.

usualsuspect1 on June 10, 2011
She came in a indian singing contest as i remember her outfit. Her vocals
are too similar throughout the whole thing. If you hear sufi/islamic
reciters pray this sufi kalam by Sultan Bahoo they pray it with all their
power. There should be emphasis during the verses which this lacks The
music is on point though which is the most important thing!

Deepak Blassi on June 10, 2011
improve picture & sound quality plzz.. HD is a must !! Coke Studio songs
need to be listened @ 320KBPS

Vasuda Sharma on June 10, 2011
great going Harshdeep...what only matters is thats you have an awsome
voice, great control amazing tone...n you have it in you.. everyone one has
opinions... let them have... in my opininon u didnt go off pitch at any
single point throughout the song.sufi prayers are indeed rendered a certain
way... but what matters is that this sounds beautiful to ears... so
overall.. kudos to you...

Pushpit Kharbanda on June 10, 2011
@iamanwer : impressed on pt 5.. hi 5!!

Pushpit Kharbanda on June 10, 2011
vocals n lyrics of cs pak are so cultural and powerful that it sweeps you
away, moreover rohail hyaat already has a great experience on how the music
@ cs should sound.. On the other hand, the genres and languages used in the
indian cs are so wast that the grooves can't be made the way they were in
the pak cs.. both are equally good but just acc to the taste.. P.S.: love
the music , not the boundaries :) love from india.. to all ..

Aparajita Nath on June 10, 2011
Dissapointment. What is wrong with the noise and sound quality? Drums not
as good as Pak!

MisterChalaque on June 10, 2011
Beautiful, but please provide lyrics and translation so that people like me
can understand how beautiful it really is.

deepak pokra on June 10, 2011
it's just beginning...loads of music is to come...waiting for Kailash Kher
nd SAAK.!!

punjabistudio on June 11, 2011
guys check out the lyrics and translations at my channel or
youtube.com/watch?v=HyLnK6JUeDo no copyright intended...just wanna share
the lyrics and translations so others can better appreciate this gem of
poetry and singing talent. help convey the message to cokestudio to add
lyrics

punjabistudio on June 11, 2011
will delete my video once cokestudio adds the captions to their video cheers

Afat qiamat on June 11, 2011
..is meen kamal Kalam kaa hey , ganay wali kaa naheen , ganay wali kai
jaghaa bay suri bhi huwi hey , or talafuz bhi ghalat raha hey , kai maqam
per. .or mouseeqi bhi is kalam say mutabaqt naheen rakhtee...

Varun Grover on June 11, 2011
Plain boring. Composition itself is inspired from Shiv Kumar Batalvi's
'maaye ni maaye main ik shikra yaar banaaya'. But Harshdeep's voice is so
monotonous she could be called 'Har-shallow Kaur'. And musical arrangement
is all over the place. A terrible start Coke Studio India. Heartbroken to
the core.

Muhamad Saad Khan on June 11, 2011
music kahin aur ja raha hai aur gaa kuch aur rahi ho woh ..

Tanmay Humnabadkar on June 12, 2011
not really satisfied with performance. it can be much much
better.

Rashid Hussain on June 12, 2011
paki one better

Muhammad Zohaib Hassan on June 12, 2011
Haq Bahoo .

sitanshu tiwari on June 13, 2011
ya i agree 2 anshul drum dnt sound as gud pak drummer...

sitanshu tiwari on June 13, 2011
ya i agree 2 anshul drum dnt sound as gud pak drummer...bt it is start so
gud..i hope it will go ahead...

Ibaad on June 13, 2011
@anshuld90 Oh yes!! He is Louis J Pinto aka Gumby ... And if u r into drums
then u might like Overload (Farhad Humayun, Papoo Saen et al. )

anshuld90 on June 13, 2011
@IbaadR u r right ,but it may b possible that the drums r sounding bad
because of the sound system (which sounds inferior to the pak's
one),because the drummer is darshan doshi,one of the topmost drummers today
in india.but i really cant say he is as gud as gumby.

Ibaad on June 13, 2011
@anshuld90 "darshan doshi" ... I had never heard of him ... I'd love to
listen to some of his previous work .

anshuld90 on June 13, 2011
@IbaadR ,sorry brother ,me too not heard of him much.but u can search
him on the net of u want ..he has his own website ..

qwertyp1234 on June 13, 2011
@humanseasons We won't forget Brazil for sure! ;)

Kabla21 on June 13, 2011
I think the problem with drum is not the drummer..he is good enough( and
the whole thing is arranged before )..the problem is sound system..somehow
the full scale of the sound is not coming here..maybe the quality if
recording..but drummer is quite nice.

forza_rosssi on June 13, 2011
Defs not a bad start. I wish CS @ MTV best of luck.

mommy on June 13, 2011
naah! it doesnt capture the essence of the song

mommy on June 13, 2011
naah! it doesnt capture the essence of the song. i guess production s not
so good yet

Pratik Varma on June 13, 2011
I loved it! It was tight.

Pratik Varma on June 14, 2011
Although I agree with one of the top comments; the drumming needs to better.

Aditya Dutta on June 14, 2011
@humanseasons ya we know it started in BRAZIL :P

suryaworklife on June 14, 2011
@rajabandish exactly

suryaworklife on June 14, 2011
@punjabistudio I enjoyed your translated version more than this. The
meaning clearly came out. Thanks punjabistudio

pkbmaharaj on June 14, 2011
The quality of sound is very inferior. They should upload a high-quality
version.

Muhamad Saad Khan on June 14, 2011
yeh drummer drum baja raha hai ya teen dabbay

skoler888 on June 14, 2011
@skoler888 ..about the x factor ..it have to be Rohail Hayatt <3

Aditya Dutta on June 14, 2011
@ajeebsa123 well theres nothing to fight about it that who copied from
where. its just that we all love music so why spoiling such a great video
with your lame comments

eizzapizza on June 14, 2011
I think she was good. ppl stop hating -_- I hate for being 1 of those ppl
who say "I'm a Paki or Indian" but i'm paki. lol. waiting to see what Coke
Studio MTV brings to the table. :)

Rav s on June 15, 2011
Thumbs up if you think Paki audience is Disliking this :) :)

REXXBAILEY on June 15, 2011
I HOPE THEY WOUD HAVE RABBI SHERGILL IN IT AS WELL IT WUD BE AWESOME TO
HAVE HIM LUCKY ALI AND ADNAAN SAMI SINGING IN HERE.. PURE BLISS :)

ritz617yt on June 15, 2011
CS Pak has set very high standards which will be tough for the Indian
version to achieve!! though every talent is available in India but somehow
after listening to Harshdeep's (though she is talented) song that zing is
missing. The sound quality is an issue here. Compare it to Meesha's Chori
chori ...u will get the difference.

ritz617yt on June 15, 2011
Coke Studio India needs to get better sound equipments for capturing live
performances.

anshuld90 on June 15, 2011
@ritz617yt ,I completely agree with you..

DarinFilms on June 16, 2011
Music, like Love, has no borders, no religion no caste or creed.

Asad Shairani on June 16, 2011
Very nice voice - but the music and composition doesn't fit it. India has a
LOT of talent - Coke Studio India should be a treat to watch. It would have
been better if the music was to reduce the hate between Pak and India,
looks like its going the other way! What madness.

Paritosh Sharma on June 16, 2011
initially i didnt like it, but i am loving it now! listening on loop!

Asif Habib on June 16, 2011
Waste of a good singer... Singer is singing well but the musicians ruined
the whole song...