amtdut on September 05, 2010
Sharmila Tagore rocks !!!
She is one of the greatest actresses ever ...
I respect her a lot ...

Mahesh on September 30, 2010
Great song. Thanks for posting.

Sunil Ithikatt on October 07, 2010
Every musician is inspired from some note or the other. The notes of the
universe don't belong to anyone. RD did a particular arrangement that may
have had a passing resemblance to the Elvis song but to call it a copy is a
bit too much. This was inspired composing. Read wide and deep about RD and
you will realize that he was in the same league as Mozart for his musical
arrangements. A genius for the ages.

FannaIshqMe on October 13, 2010
love this song kishor kumar is so great

nimmipournami on October 14, 2010
A nice song ... best lyrics.. Sharmilatagore very nice..

ofrnd87 on October 16, 2010
yar i love it..great voice great music & sweet..

mera us se hai pehle ka nata koi ..jaane "wo " ya jane na.. :)

sandss16 on October 19, 2010
Kishore magic continues.

manimajra1 on October 30, 2010
It is not a copy. Just mukhda is inspired by the Yellow Rose. Rest of the song is different. Even the rhythm is different. Melody is much more complete.

gimmy007singh on October 30, 2010
most awesome song of the century!!!!!!!!!!!11 love it like anything

5555yuvi on November 08, 2010
Such a lovely song, touches old strings and remind all those nostalgic moments.

Maya Majumdar on November 10, 2010
@manimajra1 , You're probably one of those snobs who always think low for
any Indian's rare feat. What a lovely song given by RD, this type of
comment is not just acceptable. OK if U find or have that original post it
here kindly. We 'll be thankful to U.

manimajra1 on November 10, 2010
@mayajamjam Please read the message carefully before replying. And read abhlash8's comment also. U will realize how wrong u r.

ABDUL hai on November 10, 2010
yes kishore was a versatile singer great voice

sadikshyamayagarchhu on November 19, 2010
I love it , I have been fallen in love with a nepali girl, I can forget her even a second form my mind. may be we have been known each in our life before!

sadikshyamayagarchhu on November 19, 2010
I love it , I have been fallen in love with a nepali girl, I can forget her even a second form my mind. may be we have been known each in our life before!

Tamseel Ahmed on November 26, 2010
good one but sorry to say one more copy tune by RDB

Jamie Kaur on November 26, 2010
It is true sometimes we meet someone with whom we are having Karmic
connection. And it is also true that sometimes the other does not feel
strongly as we can feel for him. This is indeed a very beautiful song which
connects us with the feeling of past lives. Thanks sarkasticgenius for this
amazing upload.

01ashine on December 04, 2010
Beautiful lyrics...n strange is this life!!!~

santoshmrsinha1982 on December 13, 2010
I just love this song, its very Romantic..

naziasalehalesayi on December 14, 2010
JAANE TU YA JAANE NA !!!!SALEH I LOVE U HAYATY.I WISH I COULD TRANSLATE THEM TO U N MKE U FEEL HOW FORTUNATE IT IS TO FALL IN LOVE WIT U ANA AHEBIK .

leteveryoneknow on December 20, 2010
Elvis Presley must be credited, not Burman. Yellow Rose of Texas

Dheeraj Sharma on December 22, 2010
@leteveryoneknow WTH ? there's hardly any resemblance between this n yellow
rose of texas.keep your opinion to yourself

kirit4201 on December 24, 2010
kabhi juda hona nahi...

leteveryoneknow on December 27, 2010
@dheeraj997 dheeraj rakho! And patiently listen to yellow rose of texas.
Its unbelievable that you can not find resemblance between the tunes in
each song. Burman certainly was heavily inspired by the tune originally
drawn out by Presley.

Dheeraj Sharma on December 30, 2010
@leteveryoneknow hehe i'm just fine ! as i said there's very little
resemblance...just the basic few notes...at most u can it may have
influenced Burman but saying that Elvis should be credited for this song is
way over the line.

Bidyut Gogoi on February 20, 2011
I love this song becoz when i listen this particular song My old
day(College Days) to my mind.. I will never forget you Ap..ta...

003shivani on February 22, 2011
I saw this movie yesterday on Zoom and watched it from the middle. I had
missed this one but watched the version in which the little kid sings with
Shashi. It was sooo touching! I came to check out the original. Both are
awesome. Such a classic and lovely song!

Satrajit Gupta on February 23, 2011
Those who say this is a copy of Elvis's song are actually jealous of the
unparalleled Musical heritage of India. They are so limited in their
imagination that they fail to realize that in the world of Music different
cultures enrich each one's music by assimilation. Had there been no such
experiments in Music, we would have turned as blunt as the Elvis followers
are now. Salute to RD for whatever he created, all are as sweet as nectar.

Satrajit Gupta on February 23, 2011
And the song completely differs at the note when Kishoreda sings "Jane tu
ya jane na".barring the first two lines which are same as Elvis's (with
all respect for the great Elvis)

kavi yadav on March 02, 2011
i love this song nd ye song mere best frnd k liye mujhe ise achha song or
koi nahi lagta uske liye love u my dear frnd nd kishore also..

3kavi on March 02, 2011
i love this song nd ye song mere best frnd k liye mujhe ise achha song or koi nahi lagta uske liye love u my dear frnd nd kishore also.

Satish Sasikumar on March 07, 2011
@BOMBAYMANN2 ..Sushma Shrestha is the real name of Poornima a Nepali singer

NpNGames on March 25, 2011
11 people who DISLIKED this may fall from the hill on which the song was
shot... :P

Geeta Jain on March 31, 2011
we four friends bunked the college saw this movie in 1973 or4

Deepankar Choudhury on April 07, 2011
I dedicate this song for my best net friend.. Guess...This is our
friendship anthem.

dips7246 on April 07, 2011
I dedicate this song to my best net friend..
Guess...This is our friendship anthem.

zaineethegreatest on April 26, 2011
@psooryalall RD Burman and Kishore Kumar -  the 2 GODS of plagiarism and thats the truth even this song is a copy of "The Yellow Rose Of Texas" by elvis.

yourasim on May 08, 2011
@NpNGames Those who disliked this song may be they heard the original
version :) heyyyyyy I liked this song maa qasam :D

cbrcoder on May 12, 2011
Even though this song is straight lift from Elvis's "Yellow Rose of Texas",
it still is much better than original one!

Shrishti97 on May 16, 2011
I just love this song like anything

Avinash Bhageloe on May 22, 2011
Mera Tujhse Hai Pehle Ka Naata Koi Yoonhi Nahin Dil Lubhaata Koi Mera
Tujhse Hai Pehle Ka Naata Koi Yoonhi Nahin Dil Lubhaata Koi...:)

prabhjot jolly on May 28, 2011
@NpNGames make that 13 people... lol

NpNGames on May 28, 2011
@prabhjotjolly hehe right!

td04031994 on June 01, 2011
this is truely a nice and good song

ravimontudo on June 05, 2011
most loving song i have ever heard

zozolito1 on June 10, 2011
beauty, bring back sweet memoies

Dilip S. Coulagi on June 20, 2011
A sweet waltz, bound to be romantic. Please post details of the music
director, poet and singer..thanks for posting.

Julie Mango on June 21, 2011
Oldies R goldies! beautiful song

ruby neelam on June 28, 2011
@NpNGames - please do't wish so bad for them, they already had
relationship/ alcohol withdrawal symptoms.

whizbang1111 on July 03, 2011
@geetajain55 wah Geeta Ji