junoon1472 on November 23, 2007
i love this song..beautiful lyrics

wtc175 on April 13, 2008
Another Bollywood rip-off from the West!

wtc175 on April 13, 2008
Another Bollywood rip-off from a Western tune! Badly done at that.

Dee Thakore on May 09, 2008
this song is copy from Elvis Presley_Yellow rose of Texas

Steve Austin on May 10, 2008
this music is done the most genius musician of all times

Steve Austin on May 10, 2008
This music is done by genius musiician of all times - R.D.Burman

kk175812 on May 17, 2008
To derubala and wctI75
1 don't care whether the song was copy either from ELVIS OR IBLIS... it is a nice song... and I believe everyone who has watched Aag Gale Laja will agree with me...

Even some western songs also copied from third world country. be matured please!!!

kk175812 from Malaysia

wtc175 on June 02, 2008
It's stealing! RD Burman didn't pay any royalties to the originator.He
didn't even give them any credit. Good or bad result, its simply wrong and
unethical.

insipid4444 on June 03, 2008
music,thats what matters the most!Intellectual property is hard to define,especially in MUSIC,since the words and tunes are later varied!Burman's music was uniquely Indian/subcontinent,since he also wrote a fantastic amount of original Bengali music based on Tagore.He was a genius who will be missed!He died at an very early age,,AND ALSO ALMOST BROKE...SOhe obviously couldnt have made that much financial gains for his art!
Hence if it wasnt for people like him,,there would be no BOLLYWOOD!

wtc175 on June 03, 2008
Totally irreleant as to the quantity pinched. If YOU were a composer and
someone stole a basic theme you created without acknowledgement or payment
you would not be happy I'm sure. As to Mercedes /Tat etc - well two wrongs
don't make a right. There are avenues to pay people royalties if using
someone else's stuff - we all have to survive and its only fair that we pay
for it - especially as he was no doubt RD was paid quite well for his
composing in films.

wtc175 on June 03, 2008
Ha!Ha! You're right - I don't speak Hindi or Urdu...but I do SING in Hindi.
Also, as a composer I understand fully that it's no different to someone
pinching, say, your prize rose and entering it in a competition and winning
a prize with it. Or making a film of your idea and making money out of it.
Would you think that acceptable? I'm sure you'd not worry about the
benefits to mankind if it was YOUR idea that was pinched. Wrong is wrong
whichever way you look at it.

entertain11 on June 04, 2008
Heart Relation Happens Naturally This Is what This Song Is For.

wtc175 on June 04, 2008
The thing is, plagiarism is rife within Bollywood music scene - going back
to the 1940's. I think its fine - but have the courtesy to give credit to
the original composer - and pay the royalties necessary - it's not much to
pay actually. This gives recognition to the original composer which is more
important than the money in a lot of cases. Finally we have to ask why the
need to copy? RD, ShankerJaikshan, Lax.Pyrelal, Kal.Anandji etc are all
talented enough without resorting to copying.

madhumass on June 15, 2008
It may be better but that still doesn't make it original. I agree, the
pinching in this tune is lesser than the blatant copying seen in many other
B'wood composers.

sidthegr8est on July 07, 2008
ummm...well it's a song..basically
just stop arguing over it...i like the song and so many others do too...that should'nt taint the original in any way

x7890x on July 10, 2008
1ST OF ALL
life isnt fair
everyone copies each others work! its better to get over it than fighting over. its not like its gonna change

mahbub2345 on July 13, 2008
Copying is disgusting. Though the tune is superb, credit must go to elvis priestley

curiousthinker on July 14, 2008
its nothing like yellow roses of taxes!!! what are u talking about not the theme or the tune.

redone00 on July 22, 2008
thx for posting, great job...

bibekmishra on July 23, 2008
great song !! Nice One. Even popular today.

AlishaB on July 30, 2008
Thanks to Jaane Tu...Ya Jaane Na

Gullali on August 03, 2008
I just saw the movie jaane tu ya jaane na...of imran khan!!
Jai sang this song for aditi at the airport that was just soooooo cute.!!!
(thats why i checked out this song)

Raziul Islam on August 08, 2008
This is an ALL TIME BLOCKBUSTER song. I like this song from very early.
But...I believe...after the Movie "Jaane Tu...Ya Jaane Na" released ...the
song become more popular. Hats off to R. D. Burman and the team of the
Movie..."Jaane Tu...Ya Jaane Na".

notigyal on August 14, 2008
i lvv dat song...thnxx alottttt

squ34ky on August 29, 2008
Thank you wtc175 for exposing this blatant plagiarism. For those who don't
know, the main tune for this song is a complete rip-off of an old American
folk song called "Yellow Rose of Texas". Yes, the great RD Burman stole
this tune without acknowledging it's origins. Don't believe me? Then watch
this video: youtube(dot)com/watch?v=EXyVENc05_c .

saburyusi on September 12, 2008
can u plz upload this movie here on youbtube. i love this movie and its sonngs...

fafarid2008 on September 20, 2008
يا سلام على افلام زمان .قمة ي الروعة.شكرا بوليود. مع تحيات خالد .

ManishS19 on September 21, 2008
listen to the lyrics and be happy man.

khakhaled007 on October 02, 2008
انا من وظع الاغنية الشهيرة جانيتوا في اليوتيب ارجوا ان تتمتعوا بها .خالد .
ام البواقي في 02 10 2008.

sab4670 on October 17, 2008
j'ai grandit avec se film , c'etait mon cendrillon a moi merci.
.

sanjayupadhyayraj on October 20, 2008
Have you even heard the video your touting to be the source of all
creativity !!

squ34ky on October 21, 2008
Don't mangle my words. I didn't say it was the source of all creativity,
but that the song was the uncredited inspiration for the main melody in
this song. And yes, I have seen it. It is but one version of this popular
folk song. It seems Youtube has put a space in the video id when I posted
the comment. Here it is again (hopefully: watch?v=EXyVENc05_c

sanjayupadhyayraj on October 22, 2008
I apologize for the ``creativity'' comment. I did figure out the address of
the song and did listen to it before posting my comment. So to reiterate:
``The yellow rose of Texas'' does not remind me of ``Tera Mujhse Hai''. In
fact, if I hear the Yellow Rose, although familiar I would never guess that
it is a precursor to ``Tera Mujhse''.

manel to on November 03, 2008
can anyone tell me were can we download this movie?and the portuguese
subtitles.

Cameron Khan on November 09, 2008
o wow thanx for video with sub title helps ppl like me who doesnt
understand hindi .. yay .. thx

akutakbetul on November 16, 2008
hei can someone tell me where to download this my fav movie...
or u all just put in the youtube so me can see

Ajay Shah on December 18, 2008
i love this song..thank you!! tera mujhse hain pehle ke naata koiii...yun
hi nahi dil lubhaata koi!!wah wah..

samteke on December 20, 2008
woooooooooooooow..!

dillagi sing on December 28, 2008
ma fav...its just amazing!

indianG65 on December 28, 2008
its beautiful...

dhruvpatel0909 on December 30, 2008
My favorite song, great lyrics. just loved it.

manav0011 on January 17, 2009
manisha
kya kahi batten waqt ki dhool se mit jaati hai
nahin acanak koi hawa us parat ko hata deti hai aur sab kuch pehla sa ho jata hai mera man na hai lamhe kabhi marte nahin ye chalte rehte hai palte rehte hai haa tum jaise use ignore jaroor karte hain kya yaddon ki dhund tumhare hatane se hat jati hai
nahin na bas yahi pyar hai
manu

munsiv on January 26, 2009
How does he manage 2 skate with another girl in arms... in those days.. Hats off 2 director.

fadu1978 on January 29, 2009
nice song... my wife and i love it. heeru pls come back... =(

Eshani Pandya on February 24, 2009
i freakin luv this song!!!

changjiin on March 14, 2009
lovely song, great lyrics..my all time fav..

Kavs1104 on March 14, 2009
Amazingly true song..really touched my heart.. :)

qaisarcom on March 15, 2009
thats really true jan oOo.oOo. Its not what i am doing its what is
happening! out of my control, i don`t know why i am always thinking about
and why i felt from our first meeting that i know you from long ago? Do you
know why is that? because i have no idea about it

himanv on March 16, 2009
well, to be fair, only the repeating stanzas pick the "Yellow Rose of
Texas" theme, and that too not in the lyrics of the song, just its rythmic
layout. But you're right, it's amazing, this "inspiration"! hehe

himanv on March 16, 2009
Owing to the use of ballad meter, the lyrics are interchangeable with those
of many other songs and poems. It's no big deal that Burman didn't
acknowledge the origin, since the origin is a folk song, not one
attributable to anybody in particular. Got it? Stop bashing a good
bollywood song, and a great Indian musician.