NANDI KHANNA on March 29, 2011
SANA KHWAN E TAQDIS E MASHRIQ KAHAn HAIn(where are people,who sangg praise
of east)this is how written,nazm titled CHAKLE meaning brothel.for song
copmosititon&to make meaning easier it was changed to jinhe naaz hai
..this nazm is from sahirs diwan(collection of
poetries)TALKHIYAn,written much earlier ie 40s.ZARA MULK KE RAHBAROn KO
BULAO/YE KOOCHE YE MANZAR DIKHAO/JINHE NAAZ HAI HIND PAR UNKO LAO/JINHE
NAAZ HI HIND PAR WOH KAHAn HAIn.true red light areas are blot &disgrace on
any nation.

NANDI KHANNA on March 29, 2011
this nazm is from sahirs diwan TALKHIYAn published much earlier in 40s,so
what you heard may not seems to be true.sorry.

NANDI KHANNA on March 29, 2011
YEH GOONJE HUE QAHQAHE RAASTOn PAR/YEH CHAROn TARAF BHID SI KHIDKIYOn
PAR/YEH AAWAZEIn KHINCHTE HUE AANCHALOn PAR/JINHE NAAZ HAI HIND
PAR...YEH BHUKHI NIGAHEIn HASEENOn KI JANIB/YEH BADTE HUE HAATH
HASEENOn KI JANIB/YEH LAPKTE HUE PAANV ZEENOn KI JANIB/JINHE NAAZ HAI HIND
PAR..these two more stanzas from the nazm.

MrMohammadAhmad on April 08, 2011
one of the best songs...this is the first time i heard it but its awesome..relevant for yesterday, today and tomorrow

ChachaChooharChakia on April 23, 2011
SAHIR da koi jabaw nahi hai...

Prasenna Chinchu on April 24, 2011
what a beautiful song .my heart go searching for ...

dptxp on May 13, 2011
Guru Dutt made many great fims. With Great songs.

flyingmachine87 on May 21, 2011
@iamnotgey didn't mean he literally got alcohol poisoning when i said he
drank himself to death. he became a career alcoholic after the films
started failing and his personal life went southwards fast (his marriage
with geeta dutt went sour because of his relationship with waheeda rahman,
which itself suffered due to his alcoholism).

mukulkamat20 on May 22, 2011
acting, lyrics, singing, music, production, direction, script everything is
just awesome abt this movie

mukulkamat20 on May 22, 2011
@flyingmachine87 Gurudutt passed away due to excess consumption of sleeping
pills.. All this was due to depression

simsomari1 on July 09, 2011
kitni sachai hai.kahan hai aise shayar.

Partap Dev on July 15, 2011
yeh hai asliyt mere desh ki ya duniya ki kaha gaya bhaichra

Chando Chandi on July 15, 2011
nobody else can sing this song like rafi saab nobody can write this kind of
songs any writer yeh sab likhne ko dum and gum chahiye jo ki aaj ke bekkar
daur mein had se jyada mushkil hai

Ruchika Gupta on July 17, 2011
so true even after so many years post independence.

Rmehtacpa on July 17, 2011
...Jinhe naaz hai Hind per who kahan hai? KAHAN HAI, KAHAN HAI, KAHHAN HAI
.

mansha80 on September 01, 2011
@vvk1 bhagwan aiseeh saiyar phirseeh deeh...

ravi9999fubar on November 12, 2011
yaa we have thing about this song bcoz it represents of india bcoz is not
is not known 4 these but still it represents the truth of india.

JAMBULINGAM ARUMUGAM on November 19, 2011
what an action by Guru dutt even during 1957 itself? Guruji you are a born
actor some body say you are immoral, may be, ist all other fiml stars of
those days are pure. what about Raj kapoor, is he not cheated Nargish.

pravchaw on December 19, 2011
"Where are the people, who have pride in India?" Even by 1957 when this
movie was released the idealism of the struggle for independence was ebbing
- India was transitioning from a dream to the reality of poverty. This song
drips in sarcasm and is a denouement to the hypocrisy and two facedness of
upper middle class society.

chickucha on December 19, 2011
wow Rafisaab Wow! You have put the soul into this song!You always did! That
is the reason we all miss you still!

Soni Pratik on December 28, 2011
What a beautiful song

kushsad on January 27, 2012
even today the scene is not much different.the hypocrisy in the society leaves the vulnerable confused and melancholic. the tragedy is it was not much to celebrate when we leaned towards socialism and we can't expect any better today when market is to decide the morality.

Ajay Sharma on May 06, 2012
Yes Exactly This Congress Killers of HSRA

Ujjwal Pandit on June 16, 2012
mostly in bollywood,,u will find dirty people,,,honesty is just a word to
them,,or a dialogue at most,,i just feel that these stars or actors are
tending to have relationships whenever they get an opportunity,,where as
guru dutt is different,,he realised his mistakes,,meena kumari and geeta
dutt were pure and true,,even lata mageshkar,she was responsible actually,,

TheImprintsOftime on July 01, 2012
a soul stirring and haunting song, which brings the darkest and bitter truth of our times, our society, its pathos and pain to the fore. The nazm was penned by great sahir and is as relevant today as was about half a centuary ago. He replaced the line 'sanaa-Khwaan-e-taqdees-e-mash­riq kahaaN haiN' to 'jinhe naaz hai hind par vo kahaaN haiN' to make it more mass driven and for easy comprehension. But the real issue of girl trafficking is a slap on the face of modern India which feigns ignorance

Sreedharan Champad on September 25, 2012
Still the question is there since 1957. Jhine naaz hain Hind per woh kahan
hain? Pranam Gurda! Pranam!

Sreedharan Champad on September 27, 2012
Yes, this people are worst than British.Who.? Nafrath tho Hind se
nahi.sochlo phir kis se hoga? Hind me abhi be karodom log bhuka hain.
You should see the Adivasis of Waynad, Kerala.Do nt compare with the people
of Mumbai, Kolkata, Delhi and Chennai.Go and see the tribals of Jharkhand,
Chathisgarh and Kerala. Then you too ask Jineh naaz...Kahan hain?

Galavya41 on September 27, 2012
I know the poor state of the villagers of Bharat..I am a member of the
Ramakrishna Mission Yuva sangh working in the Sundarbans and I have seen
the sorry state of my fellow Bharatwasis...The ones in power dont care
.Again We need a Vidroh and NO a Gandhi Bapu style andolan wont do these
people dont care much about such andolans...WE NEED a NetaJi or Bhagat
Singh style vidroh...but that wont happen if people like us continue to
remain in our homes or offices.

burusona1 on October 02, 2012
nothing can be truer than these words of this song to describe today's India!!

shree prakash Loya on October 20, 2012
Very few people know that this song was written by Sahir Ludhianvi as
response to Nehru"s statement "Mujhe Hind par naaz hai".

Nitin Pendse on December 03, 2012
जिन्हे नाझ है हिंद पर वोह कहा है? Still the same in 2012.

shree prakash Loya on March 03, 2013
Nehru made that statement in a public meeting. Sahir and many poets and
writers those days were with clear communist leanings and preferred Russian
or Chinese communist model, particularly for welfare and health care. Hence
this song.

100Aurangzeb on March 26, 2013
800,000,000 Indians live under Rs 20 a day so where is the Progress ? We
are constantly Bombarded with the New Billionaires by the Media and
Bollywood tells us everything is alright. Jinhe naaz hai hind par woh kahan
hai.

shwait verma on April 08, 2013
GuruDutt was a gem who made movies of par excelence and matchless.I request
to the new generation to see the movies of Gurdutt and get some lesson. It
is rightly said that OLD IS GOLD.

Sujeet Modak on August 26, 2013
i dont think there is mana day version

vidit tripathi on October 05, 2013
chaturvedi ji.chaar vedon keg yaata hain aap!! aapke emotions ki
kadar karta hun..par kisi bhi...kisi bhi matlab kisi bhi..aurat ke
liye apshabd istemaal aap ko shobha nahi deta!!

gaurav chaturvedi on October 06, 2013
tripathi ji aap bhi brahman kul se hi hain isiliye main bhi aapki qadr aur
izzat karta hoon, mane jo bhi kaha wo aurat ya aadmi ke baare main nahi,
balki sahi ya galat insaan ke baare main kaha, insaan matlab insaan, na ki
koi aurat ya aadmi ! :D

iub4767 on March 30, 2015
Excellent conveying of emotions through mesmering deep touching voice of
Rafi sb!"

Alok Chadha on April 02, 2015
wah wah.amazing Legends who would never return. Kya baat hain Sir