salildixit67 on July 14, 2009
awesome .
sir , agar ho sake to 'tere mandir ka hoon deepak''
load kariyega .

chamogaa on July 14, 2009
You have not only restored a beloved PM song , you have become a veritable trustee of many musical gems of the pre-1950 era. This is one of those songs that for true love birds quite likely evokes the tenderest romantic feelings on moonlit spring or summer evenings caressed by soothing breezes. Many, many thanks for graciously responding to my request.

sud60 on August 11, 2009
oh what lovely golden voice from the past..the magic in this voice...

YTvictimrumahale on January 20, 2010
I have always loved the songs from Pankaj Malik along with those from K C Dey and K L Saigal. This one a private song is really beautiful from the legend.

Thanks for making it available for the benefit of members for whom music is everything. Thanks also due to Vipan Chandra ji for having been responsible for requesting upload.

YTvictimrumahale on January 20, 2010
Sir, thanks for the initiatives in bringing this song on YT.

dubbooman on April 13, 2010
thanks for uploading this beautifull song, it has to rank as the most memorable private songs of all time, by the legend PM

Jagjit Singh Ishar on June 01, 2010
congrats 4 ur gr8 effort. i hv heard original version repeatdly being my
most favorit one. pankaj has many butiful gems 2 his credit & the man was
highly talented but 4 lata g words fail me 2 praise her. there is abode of
maa saraswati g in her vocal chords. but u hv xcelntly tried 2 recreate the
video on dalip, madhu bala. tho its difficult task 2 coincide lip movement
but u hv done as one cant judge easily. really u r gr8 & should do more as
there is an ocean of such beautiful gems with us.

myvision22 on June 01, 2010
great song, excellent sound quality, millions of thanks for the song

MoleculaRafian on June 01, 2010
@myvision22 . Thanks for the comment. Make it a Great day, MR

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on June 01, 2010
@Inaam2 Thank you for the suggestion

chandrashekharjain on June 03, 2010
Yet another great video by myvision22. Continue the good work

chandrashekharjain on June 04, 2010
Very good video creation.Close ups were quite good too. 100% lips matching
is not expected in such improvisations.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on June 05, 2010
@jagjitisher Thank you Jagjit Ji for the appreciation. This will encourage
me to do more creations on beautiful gems. mukhtar

nikuusa1 on June 17, 2010
MY FAMILY IS GREAT ADMIRE OF MR PANKAJ MULICK AND HIS RABEENDRA SANGEET, WE CONSIDER FINEST MALE VOICE IN COMMERCIAL MUSIC WORLD IN LAST 100 YEARS, MY FATHER USED TO HEAR THIS DIVINE VOICE , I DO AND MY AMERICAN BORN BOTH DAUGHTERS LOVE SERENITY AND DIVINITY OF PANKAJDA'S VOICE.REQUEST MORE AND RABEENDRASANGEET TOO.

kalakar67 on July 21, 2010
Yet another wonderful job from you.

naheemawan on July 26, 2010
Best Music ,
Best Compositon,
Best Lyrics,
Best Singers

KaleemRahman on September 12, 2010
This song is the epitome of the tender senuality and rapturous aesthetic and spiritual experience of romantic love. Here is a humble assay at creating the mood ,magic and atmosphere .

jasbongy on September 20, 2010
Excellent song which Lata ji has sung so well.Originally sung by Pankaj
Malik ji,Lata ji's tribute to great singer is very impressive. Mukhtar
Bhai, you started tgis song with the clip of ''Beiman Tore naynwa nindiya''
brilliantlly. Made for each other handsome couple chosen by you for most of
videos ,here also creates Miracle with this song. Thumbs Up. Thanks for
sharing and for being so creative with your unique videos. Bless you. Didi.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on September 21, 2010
@jasbongy Thank you Sarla Didi for such a nice comments. Your comments
always encourage me to create better and better videos. Mukhtar

chanto7 on September 26, 2010
incredible! ! very soul touching video and song.

tk yaheya on October 09, 2010
Wonderfully creative artistic work by you and it is very inspiring to note
that you made the choreograph very impressive and appropriate by bringing
into the scene some of the best talents we had on screen in the Golden
era!! Hats Off!!!

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on October 09, 2010
@chanto7 Thank you very much for your nice comments.

S Qasim Hasan Zaidi on October 29, 2010
What a profound touch you have given, Mukhtar Bhai, to the fabulous
original number of Pankaj Mullick. It was an ingenious move on your part to
substitute Lata's version and bring Madhubala in place. It is a treat for
those who know about the passionate attraction she felt towards Dilip.
Lata's divine voice and the wonderful lyrics have combined further to
enhance the magic. Thanks a lot.

chotasagar on November 03, 2010
Salaam Mukhtar Bhai, You have done excellently in your video creativity and
presented it so well that the song flows with your creation and
imagination. I must admit that I have not listened to the song previously
and now that I have, it is a very soulful song with very touching lyrics. I
admire your painstaking time and effort that you put in to your work. Best
Regards and Salaam...Siraj

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on January 04, 2011
@Svetka994 Thank you for liking my presentation

kuckudk on January 21, 2011
Mukhtar Bhai, Madhu Bala is no more but i wish that your videos should be
watched by Dilip Sahab. I am sure it will recreate the nostalgia of the
bygone era, in his heart.

ramils on January 29, 2011
What a Nice poem and how nicely sung...Amazing

khalidmumtaz100 on May 14, 2011
One of the best songs ever created. I have been listening to this since childhood with my parents and now they have gone but this song recreates the joy and the tenderness each time I listen to it. We cannot be too grateful for God's gifts to mankind and Pankaj is one of them.

aiz khan on May 22, 2011
Fabulous! I think you did a good job. Your effort proved successful. This
song, no doubt, creates nostalgia. I've selected it to practice myself on
harmonium. Thanks for your contribution in music.

arvaishnavi on June 21, 2011
thank you very much for uploading this beautiful song...i listen to this song as many times and yet want to continue listening to it forever,. this rendition is immortal...the best of the great Pankaj mullick

Sunil Jhobalia on July 19, 2011
Thanks to Myvision22 for upload This is amazing song I heard after a long
long long time and as usual Madhubala and Dilipkumar are the best pair
Nobody will ever match Madhubala's Beauty and Acting style. She was a child
movie star and God loved her more than all of us She left the legacy for us
to enjoy forever Thanks again sjhobalia Sion Bombay -22 and

hirakdutta on July 20, 2011
I've heard this song so many times. Pankaj Mullick's devine voice fills up the atmosphere with absolutely uncomparable melody.
I often listen to this song before retiring to bed to get over the stressful activities throughout the day.
The most amazing feature of these golden musical era is that there was no editting and patchwork or deafening music to cover up any flaws of the artist .
Everything was perfect and so original.

om brahma on July 21, 2011
My parents too loved Mullick, Saigal, Umadevi, Kanandevi, etc. We had this record which my dad always played on gramaphone (HMV or His Master'sVoice if you remember which you had to wind manually). it a divine experience indeed, especially the wordings, the tune, the voice and very appropriate background music that allows the human voice to be felt.

Sunil Jhobalia on September 04, 2011
Thanks to Myvision22 for the upload of this outstanding song of Pankaj
Mallick thanks again sjhobalia 9/03/2011

Sunil Jhobalia on September 21, 2011
Dear Mr Myvision22 I try to see this amazing video every night before going
to bed. Madhubala's acting in this video is outstanding and she really
shows her real love Mr Dilip Saheb. Great job done sjhobalia 9/21/2011
mubmai-22

dharambir dodd on October 25, 2011
and i sang this unique song at my retirement @ 60 IN 2002

Atiq Rahman on October 30, 2011
Excellent collection of lovely movie scenes , for MADHUBALA fans.

ajay vijh on November 01, 2011
beautifulll !!

roos ramdin on November 02, 2011
WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Suresh Mandan on November 04, 2011
Mukhtar I heard this video just a few days ago.Lata has sang it so well. I
listen to it almost every morning while travelling to my work in USA. My
mother used to remember this song while she was in Bombay of those
days..going on the pillion of my father's bicycle somewhere in Colaba.
By the time the song ends,the eyes are totally wet.Thanks

rumahale on November 15, 2011
This is superb and divine and dear to my heart. Thanks again.

Naveen Dighe on November 17, 2011
A GREAT JOB MYVISION PEOPLE LIKE YOU SPREAD HAPPINESS AND JOY

Dilip S. Coulagi on November 27, 2011
One of my favourites...presume Pankaj Mullick himself gave the music; who was the poet?

Dilip S. Coulagi on November 27, 2011
Favourite old song...presume music was by Pankaj Malik himself.
Who was the poet and the year of the original recordong by Pankaj?

Dilip S. Coulagi on November 27, 2011
IMHO there is an error in Lata's version. She sings, and you have
transcribed so: "fiza ke labon par ye CHHUP ka fasana" whereas the original
is "fiza ke labon par ye CHUP ka fasana.

Mukhtar Lyall-puri on November 27, 2011
@DilipCoulagi Dear Dilip ji, I agree with you, the correct word is "Chup"
.. silence ... Khamoshi. Thanks and best regards MUKHTAR

shaz prince on December 03, 2011
amazing song,unforgettable wordings

narinder171049 on December 12, 2011
Divine,Soul Stirring.Great music.Thanks

MrNashans on December 23, 2011
After long time heard this song, what a song & see the pain in singing this ,, Thanks a lot for it, God bless you ,,,,

Padam a on February 07, 2012
Thanks for this goodnight song ;)