tanniaimran on September 27, 2008
I am sorry to say but she does not know how to
sing a ghazal.
She lacks the delicacies which are required
for singing a ghazal.
No doubt she is a good singer, but this
does not mean she can sing everything.
Well this is what i thought...
Some people might disagree with me.

manumanish on October 06, 2008
i would rather say we cnt really compare a gazal sung by farida ji and same sung by asha ji...Farida ji has a completly her own style of singing gazal which u can say very typical gazal singer...
but as far as asha ji is concerned she has done a total fair with this gazal she has made it her own song..and sung in her own way though one thing is sure i couldnt really feeel the rendition of this gazal ..but still we cnt say that she buchred this gazal...

tanniaimran on October 07, 2008
You are right that asha ji sung it with her
own style.
But to me its no more a ghazal, it
is more closer to a song.
There is a difference between ghazal and
song singing.

sheetaan on October 15, 2008
i have never liked this version..although no one doubts her voice and stature as a highly professional singer.but i beleive too much of remixing ruined the original song.above all NO TABLA EFFECT ...stick to the basics.

omap1710 on October 15, 2008
The guitar at the starting was awfull!!!!!

scorpmaddy on October 16, 2008
awful remix..only asha's voice acts a saving grace..the simplicity in the notes is the one which mad this song a masterpiece..screwed the song with slack acoustics

sweetbear1999 on October 28, 2008
This is reality and i spend this type of time.I love this song. I pray this song will never stops.

stormvixen on November 04, 2008
I LOVE this song!!! : ) x x x

brokenwings786 on November 09, 2008
Asha did it well... but Farida's version is awesome!

amipiyu on December 07, 2008
original is awesome. Asha ji sang well too but the western instruments
have killed the beauty of the song.

AhmedSaeed84 on January 03, 2009
well it doesnt matter if its pak music or indian,for me the Original one is far better though asha is a great singer.

TrueZen9 on January 10, 2009
Asha Ji rocks ... :) heavenly voice

dekhna on January 10, 2009
Let me listen to the song argue some where else. Cannot even listen to the music without people grabbing each others shirts.
Larai jhagra bund karoo

omap1710 on January 22, 2009
no, the organ at the beginning was screwed up , everything else is perfect

PlantFL on February 07, 2009
yes credit goes to Sohail Rana .. Also Habib Wali Mohammed sang it very well

Jawwad Uddin on March 17, 2009
Orginal Voice Awsom

rinkumukherjee on March 24, 2009
She is the Indian modern song Queen... really love her..

Hasan Syed on April 08, 2009
Original song by Habib Wali is the best.

shadow0466666594 on April 18, 2009
No disrespect to Asha Ji, she is a great singer, but why did she really need to sing this? Farida Khanum's version is way better.

nandu1f on April 22, 2009
wonderful. Superb.

Cyrus Syed on May 01, 2009
Asha is a great singer but she ruined this ghazal

naveed705 on May 03, 2009
Asha well done but you are still long away from Farida.This song was naturally written for farida,nobody can sing it the way she had sung.

atanughosal on May 11, 2009
This is exactly what happens when a pure classical piece is attempted to be commercliased for mass acceptance. FaridaJi's version is real gem of a 'classical' ,based on Yeman, AshaJi's version is a "pop music" ... and that explains all these comments

sourabhakapablo on May 13, 2009
Love Asha ji's version...it has the appeal for the younger generation.

pakgroove on May 21, 2009
no doubt dear, Farida jee is the best. we also respect the asha jee too.

zshah78 on May 26, 2009
this is no gud!!!!! what can i say!

aleenaa on June 04, 2009
she ruined the song . ALAS

antariks on June 05, 2009
Indians chor ho ya jo bhi ho tumhara baap hain...tumlog to saale bhikhari ho.

yasirsultanpak on June 07, 2009
i am a big fan of asha g, she sung it beautifully but fareeda khanum has sung it stunningly beautiful. hey fatima i suggest you to listen in fareeda khanum's voice too

ph0ul on June 29, 2009
not 60s... its from the movie Badal aur Bijli released in 1973

Hastalavistas on July 10, 2009
thanks for the advice Maulana!!!

Now do your work.

nickkohri on August 01, 2009
And the version by Habib Wali is still the best.

Hastalavistas on August 02, 2009
How can i judge that you are a girl if you can write such a vulgar language.

Maheshsawant07 on August 06, 2009
Bass Meri Aakhri Khwahish Puri kar di bosss kab se dhund raha tha

2002salman on August 10, 2009
cheating kar k hi ache gane bante hain indians k after all asal ghazal to hamari hai...:P

mulan400 on August 14, 2009
The least they could've done is credit Sohail Rana as the composer and music director for this beautiful ghazal.

sonusonu89 on August 15, 2009
ye song ko gana koi Aasan baat nahi
Asha bhosle ye song aap ke baas ki baat nahi wohi baat ho gayi naach na janey aanhan terha ...ab ye hi song Shafqat AMANAT ki awaaz main bhi sun kar dekyein phir pata lagey ga gana kiss ko kehtey hain ...

shaiyanne17 on August 17, 2009
she did a good job with the song...i enjoyed the video.i love this song
but the original version.

matsharma on August 19, 2009
Well...this album was Asha bhosle's tribute to the World famous Ghazal singers..like...Mehndi hasan, Ghulam ali, Farida khanum, Jagjit singh
I think this will end the debate now...

Inspire me. on August 27, 2009
song is very well picturised.

Shafiq Khan on September 04, 2009
Original singer was Habib wali Mohammad and the move was Bazi, if I,m right

Sabbu14 on September 19, 2009
lov the song!! best song evaaaaa!!! thanx fo the song!!! this song makes me cry everytime i listen to this song!! ;P

apm292 on October 10, 2009
agree...but it was to inform those who thinks that it is an purely Indian song.

pester1 on October 13, 2009
What does ghazal means ?
Anyone?
Is that the kind of song that made prince Siddhartha think of death?

sk8kar89 on November 01, 2009
"do not insist to leave today
please sit here before me
il die, il be looted
please dont say things like this
do not insist to leave today"

its about love. as u can see in the video, there are couples breaking up and one says "do not not insist to leave today"

zehra1792 on November 02, 2009
i love this song:)

2861996 on November 12, 2009
who is this guy who was yelling at the girl?

2861996 on November 12, 2009
originally it is sung by habib wali muhammed.

mofalam on November 18, 2009
correction, it is originally habib wali mohammaed, a pkistani film probably
1972, music by sohail rana, not nisar bazmi.

maahi3 on November 27, 2009
gr8 song i jus lvu diz song